Skip to content

KeyCorp

US · KEY #877 by market cap Listed 1970
19.45 -0.58 -2.90%
Periodic snapshot; not a real-time feed. · 2026-11-20 20:02

Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range

P/B ratio 1.30 In line with history 65th percentile
5-year average 27.73 · #230 of 352 in Banks - Regional
P/E ratio 10.69 In line with history 61st percentile
5-year average -8.36 · forward 9.39 · #109 of 311 in Banks - Regional
P/S ratio 2.65 In line with history 49th percentile
5-year average 2.78 · forward 2.40 · #98 of 353 in Banks - Regional

Vs. peers Banks - Regional

Company Market cap P/E (TTM) P/B Div yield
KeyCorp (KEY) 20.54B 10.69 1.30 4.22%
HDFC Bank (HDB) 140.70B 18.65 1.61 1.29%
ICICI Bank (IBN) 127.42B 20.33 3.04 0.70%
Mizuho Financial (MFG) 107.69B 11.96 1.65 1.03%
U.S. Bancorp (USB) 87.34B 10.88 1.46 3.75%
PNC Financial Services (PNC) 84.56B 11.35 1.36 3.33%

Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.

Morningstar

★★★★☆ Fair value23.40 Economic moatNone UncertaintyMedium Capital allocationStandard

Trading 20.3% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.

Analyst note

KeyCorp delivered good third-quarter results, with total revenue up 10% year over year and net interest margin expanding 6 basis points sequentially to 2.95%.

Why it matters: KeyCorp's average deposit growth of 2.4% sequentially, along with just a 3-basis-point increase in interest-bearing deposit costs, compared favorably with peers. Consumer lending remained a headwind, but strong commercial loan growth more than offset lower consumer balances, lifting average loan balances by 1.4% from the prior quarter. However, management guided to moderating loan growth in the fourth quarter. KeyCorp raised its full-year average loan growth guidance by 1 percentage point, to 5%, and tightened its net interest income growth guidance to 10%, from 9%-11%.

The bottom line: As we incorporate the latest results and updated guidance, we expect to raise our $23.10 fair value estimate for no-moat-rated KeyCorp by a mid-single-digit percentage. The shares look undervalued. We expect to raise our 2026 and 2027 net interest income growth forecasts, driven by margin expansion and stronger commercial loan growth. That said, we still view the bank’s fourth-quarter 2027 net interest margin target of 3.25% as quite lofty, as it implies roughly 30 basis points of expansion from the third quarter of 2026. We also plan to raise our 2026 investment banking fee income forecast to incorporate the strong performance in the third quarter, partially driven by the acquisition of Clearwater. Accordingly, we expect to raise our 2026 compensation expense forecast to reflect the higher variable compensation tied to investment banking fees.

Big picture: We do not think personal artificial intelligence tools are a significant near-term threat to KeyCorp's deposit base, as banking relationships are built on trust. Significant liability and privacy concerns might also prompt banks to prevent third-party AI agents from accessing their platforms.

Fair value

We are increasing our fair value estimate to $23.40 per share from $23.10. Around two-thirds of the increase comes from the time value of money, and the remainder from various updates to our earnings forecast. Our valuation is equivalent to 1.9 times the bank’s tangible book value as of Sept. 30, 2026 (and 1.5 times TBV after removing AOCI effects). We use a cost of equity assumption of 8.9%.

We forecast average loan growth of around 4.2% in 2026, with the bank continuing to see some deliberate runoff of its mortgage and other consumer loans, partially offset by growth in commercial loans. We expect another year of NIM expansion of around 22 basis points in 2026, to 2.96%, following a 51-basis-point expansion in 2025. This leads to a 9% increase in 2026 net interest income. We expect the bank's longer-term net interest margin to normalize to around 2.90% as the higher-yielding hedges eventually roll off its balance sheet. We forecast its net interest income to grow at a CAGR of 3.6% from 2025 to 2035.

We expect fee income to grow at 4% in 2026, driven by broad-based growth in deposit service charges, investment banking fees, and asset-based fees, with some headwinds in the bank’s commercial mortgage servicing income. In the long run, we forecast annual fee income growth of around 2.8%.

We expect expense growth of 4.5% in 2026, driven primarily by compensation expense and technology spending. We expect expense growth of 2.8%-3.5% thereafter. By the end of our 10-year forecast, we expect the bank’s efficiency ratio to reach 61.7%, missing management’s ambitious target range of 54%-56%.

We now project credit costs to come down in 2026, as the improvement in credit costs is better than our expectations at the beginning of the year. We model a net charge-off ratio of 38 basis points, better than the 41 basis points in 2024 and 2025. We expect a return on tangible common equity of 14.0% through the cycle compared with our estimate of the bank’s cost of equity at 8.9%. This again falls short of management’s target return range of 16%-19%.

Economic moat

We assign KeyCorp a Morningstar Economic Moat Rating of none because it does not possess durable cost advantages or meaningful switching costs consistent with our bank moat framework. While we project the bank will earn returns above its cost of capital (8.9%), we still forecast it will tend to be on the lower end of its peers on a normalized basis. We would like to see further improvement in the bank’s deposit franchise before awarding it a moat.

We believe bank moats are derived primarily from cost advantages and switching costs. We see cost advantages from three primary factors: a low-cost deposit base, excellent operating efficiency, and conservative underwriting. Regulatory costs must also be considered. We argue that KeyCorp exhibits no strong signs of cost advantages or strong switching costs.

KeyCorp tends to have a higher cost of deposits than the other banks we cover. Despite having a better mix of non-interest-bearing deposits, KeyCorp has historically had to pay slightly higher rates on its pool of interest-bearing deposits. KeyCorp lost 26.4% of its non-interest-bearing deposits in 2023, the worst among our regional bank coverage (average lost 17.6%), reinforcing our view that KeyCorp doesn’t have a strong deposit franchise. The swaps portfolio also worked against the bank in the last rate-hiking cycle, as the bank was trying to lock in rates when facing ultralow rates during covid but missed some of the asset repricing benefits from higher rates in 2023. As a result, the bank’s net interest margin and credit-adjusted net interest margin (adjusted for loan-loss provisioning) were the lowest among our regional bank coverage in 2022 and 2023, though its net interest margin started to recover in 2024.

KeyCorp has historically run less efficiently than top banks we cover, averaging a mid-60s efficiency ratio. This stems from its dispersed branch network, lower deposit market share concentration, and investment banking focus. The bank’s footprint spans 16 states, split between Eastern markets (Midwest/Northeast) and Western markets (Washington, Oregon, Alaska, Colorado, Utah). Given this fragmentation, we forecast KeyCorp’s efficiency ratio stays on the high end relative to moaty peers. Its investment banking fee income, with a higher compensation ratio than traditional banking, further weighs on efficiency.

In terms of credit costs, KeyCorp has not historically been a solid underwriter and has generally performed worse than its peers through the past several downturns. While KeyCorp did not make it through the 2008-09 global financial crisis unscathed, we believe it has been a more conservative lender since then, having rotated out of the riskier and out-of-footprint construction loans that had hurt it in past cycles. The bank’s performance during the pandemic confirms this. Looking ahead, we think the bank’s credit costs should be generally in line with the broader US banking industry.

Regulatory costs matter at the industry level and for KeyCorp specifically. The US banking system has improved over the last decade, with capital levels at all-time highs and stronger postcrisis regulation. Despite intense competition, the largest banks by assets have earned higher returns on equity for decades and still do. Our long-run outlook is positive, given the US’ stable democracy, steady gross domestic product growth, and reserve currency status. KeyCorp is not large enough to be considered a global systemically important bank and therefore avoids some of the more onerous regulatory capital requirements. It is large enough to be subject to the Federal Reserve’s stress tests because it has more than $100 billion in assets, but it only has to go through the full process every two years. The bank also avoids extra liquidity coverage and funding ratio requirements. Overall, because the bank avoids much of the additional regulation that larger peers face, we view its regulatory burden as slightly advantageous. While we think KeyCorp could benefit from some additional scale, it is small enough to avoid some of the extra costs faced by its largest peers. Further requirements will be triggered if KeyCorp surpasses $250 billion in assets. We view the March 2026 Basel III endgame proposal and 2025 stress test changes as mostly positive. The key change for banks between $250 billion and $700 billion in assets is including accumulated other comprehensive income in common equity Tier 1 capital, which KeyCorp should handle well. KeyCorp already has an adjusted CET1 ratio (adjusting for AOCI) of 8.6%, above its regulatory minimum of 7.7% at the end of September 2026.

Switching costs exist in banking services, but KeyCorp lacks the attributes to earn a moat from them. Its average fee income ratio of 40% is high among regional peers, driven mainly by wealth and trust management, investment banking, and digital banking at Laurel Road. Scale and reputation matter in these businesses, and KeyCorp is competitive but not a standout. These segments are useful add-ons that diversify revenue and serve clients well, but don't yet provide durable structural switching cost advantages.

KeyCorp has a stronger focus on capital markets, using these services to complement its commercial banking operations. It doesn’t have a large trading business, focusing primarily on merger advisory, debt underwriting, and equity underwriting. High-level indicators of an investment bank’s intangible assets include league table position, participation in high-profile transactions, and revenue generated by its bankers. In the middle market where KeyCorp focuses, deal sizes and services rendered don’t scale as much as those of dominant investment banks. We also wonder how returns will evolve over the next 10 years as larger peers migrate more into the middle market and as private credit (nonbank lenders) expands aggressively into this area.

Bull case

KeyCorp's investment banking fees could be a major fee income growth driver if recently hired senior bankers' productivity gets up to speed.

KeyCorp's net interest margin could expand further from a larger earnings asset mix from commercial lending.

If the bank is successful in increasing its fee income penetration with its commercial lending clients, it could improve its return profile further.

Bear case

In the event of a recession, the bank would face lower balance-sheet growth and higher credit costs.

KeyCorp has an odd branch footprint that may be difficult to truly optimize, leading to structurally lower efficiency and less revenue synergies compared with peers.

KeyCorp's runoff of its residential mortgage and other consumer loans will drag on its balance sheet growth in the next few years.

By Maoyuan Chen

Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:37 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.

KeyCorp discussion 0 comments

Add a comment