Skip to content

American Financial

US · AFG #1356 by market cap Listed 1970
139.02 -1.05 -0.75%
Live - 5344 symbols - heartbeat 229s ago · 2026-10-08 03:31
After-hours 139.02 0.00%
Overnight 139.02 0.00%
Market cap
11.53B
P/B
2.39
EPS
10.08
Reader sentiment Are you bullish or bearish on AFG?

Anonymous reader poll. Unscientific, not investment advice.

Analyst consensus 3 analysts

Buy
Avg price target 161.33 +16.0%
Price target rangecurrent 139.02
Low153.00
Avg161.33
High175.00
Buy 33% Hold 67% Sell 0%
Recent ratings (14)
DateFirmAnalystRatingTarget
2026-08-28 Piper Sandler -- HOLD 156.00
2026-08-17 Wells Fargo -- BUY 175.00
2026-08-11 KBW -- HOLD 153.00
2026-08-10 Piper Sandler -- HOLD 156.00
2026-07-08 KBW -- HOLD 148.00
2026-05-26 Piper Sandler -- HOLD 140.00
2026-05-12 KBW -- HOLD 140.00
2026-05-07 Wells Fargo -- BUY 158.00
2026-03-24 KBW -- HOLD 140.00
2026-03-12 KBW -- HOLD 134.00
2026-02-10 KBW -- HOLD 134.00
2026-02-04 Piper Sandler -- HOLD 139.00
2026-01-06 KBW -- HOLD 136.00
2025-11-06 Piper Sandler -- HOLD 139.00

Quant vs Street three independent views, side by side

Momentum strategy signal
Hold
Analyst consensus
Buy

Signals diverge - worth digging into why.

Not investment advice. The factor grade ranks this stock on fundamentals against StockVane's covered universe; the momentum strategy signal is a rules-based backtest, not a recommendation; analyst consensus reflects sell-side coverage. The three use different methods and can reasonably disagree.

Price target trend monthly average, last 3 years

Earnings history price reaction on the day

PeriodReport dateSessionOptions expectedActual move
2026/Q2 2026-08-04 After close ±4.02% +4.36% (beat)
2026/Q1 2026-04-29 After close ±4.17% +2.97% (in line)
2025/Q4 2026-02-03 After close ±4.02% -3.12% (in line)
2025/Q3 2025-11-04 After close ±4.68% +2.80% (in line)
2025/Q2 2025-08-05 After close ±5.39% +2.69% (in line)
2025/Q1 2025-05-06 After close ±5.36% -6.14% (beat)
2024/Q4 2025-02-04 After close -- -6.23%
2024/Q3 2024-11-05 After close ±4.58% +4.99% (beat)
2024/Q2 2024-08-06 After close ±7.25% -0.70% (in line)
2024/Q1 2024-05-01 After close ±5.17% -0.82% (in line)
2023/Q4 2024-02-06 After close ±4.73% +2.11% (in line)
2023/Q3 2023-11-01 After close ±5.71% -2.09% (in line)

"Options expected" is the pre-earnings options market's implied move (a straddle-style estimate), shown next to what actually happened.

Quote time 2026-10-08 03:31:39 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.