Allstate
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Insurance - Property & Casualty
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Allstate (ALL) | 66.07B | 6.06 | 2.18 | 1.59% |
| Chubb Ltd (CB) | 141.99B | 13.03 | 1.94 | 1.07% |
| Progressive (PGR) | 133.67B | 11.66 | 3.88 | 6.01% |
| The Travelers Companies (TRV) | 82.02B | 10.34 | 2.78 | 1.20% |
| WR Berkley (WRB) | 29.09B | 16.56 | 3.03 | 0.49% |
| Cincinnati Financial (CINF) | 28.64B | 10.95 | 1.77 | 1.98% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 28.5% above Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Allstate posted another very strong quarter, driven by multiple tailwinds, though we question how long this will last.
Why it matters: The adjusted annualized return on equity in the quarter was 26%, well above the company's historical average, driven by industry tailwinds on both the underwriting and investment side. The underlying combined ratio for personal auto ticked up a bit to 89.8% from 86.0% last year and 87.6% in the previous quarter but remains quite attractive in an absolute sense. Reported results have been buoyed by especially strong favorable reserve development in recent quarters, and that has continued. We think some favorable claims trends are offsetting weaker pricing for now, but this is unlikely to persist. Homeowners looks more stable, with the underlying combined ratio coming in at 60.1% this quarter, compared with 59.8% last year and 61.5% in the previous quarter. But we think industry pricing might be weakening, which could make it difficult to maintain this level for long.
The bottom line: We will maintain our $191 fair value estimate for the no-moat company and see shares as materially overvalued. In addition to strong underwriting results, Allstate continues to see some uplift from higher interest rates, with investment income up 24% year over year. Like its peers, Allstate is seeing tailwinds across its business, and we expect near-term results to remain strong. But we see insurance as a highly competitive and inherently mean-reverting industry. Typically, pricing is the lever to move returns back in line with historical averages, and we see signs that this is starting to occur. We expect returns for Allstate and its peers to normalize over the next few years, and we think the market is overly focused on recent results rather than this long-term reality.
We are encouraged by the recent trend in market share. Allstate remains tied to the captive agent channel, which has been losing share for years, and we worry management will make value-destructive decisions to maintain it. But policies in force in both auto and homeowners were up 3% year over year, and growth has trended modestly upward over the past few quarters. Increasing growth during a favorable market environment is a positive signal on this front, in our view.
Fair value
We are increasing our fair value estimate for Allstate to $191 per share from $176 due to time value since our last update, some adjustments to our near-term assumptions based on the company's recent performance, and a change in our cost of equity assumption. Our fair value estimate is equivalent to 1.7 times 2025 year-end book value and 1.9 times book value excluding goodwill and accumulated other comprehensive income.
We think the market shift away from the captive agent channel and Allstate's leading position in a mature industry limit its long-term growth prospects. We also think a weaker pricing picture in personal auto will be a headwind for premium growth. We assume earned premiums for the P&C segment to increase at a fairly modest 3% compound annual growth rate, with somewhat higher growth in the near term.
Allstate produced very strong underwriting results in the early part of the pandemic, but results deteriorated significantly in the following years, and the company endured significant underwriting losses in 2022 and 2023. Underwriting results improved markedly starting in 2024, and we think that underwriting results will remain strong in the near term as recent pricing increases boost underwriting margins. We expect higher interest rates to boost near-term results and produce stronger investment income.
In the back half of our projection period, we expect the combined ratio to start to creep up, as higher interest rates and improved investment income reduce the need for underwriting income and industry results start to normalize. Our projections include one large catastrophe loss year to reflect the volatility of the company's operations. Overall, this leads to our assumption of an average combined ratio of 96% in its P&C operations during our forecast horizon, a bit below the company's average over the past five years.
Our projections result in an average adjusted return on equity of 17%, with much stronger results in the near term. We use a cost of equity of 8.9% in our valuation.
Economic moat
We assign Allstate a no moat rating.
In general, property-casualty insurers do not benefit from favorable competitive positions. Industry competition is fierce, and the products are essentially commodities. Furthermore, participants do not know their cost of goods sold for a number of years, allowing them to underprice policies without knowing it. Firms have a large incentive to chase growth without regard for profitability, a cycle that repeats itself as competitors are forced to match artificially low prices or risk losing business.
In our view, Allstate has historically had a differentiated model through its use of captive agents and its bundling strategy. That said, the company’s historical returns suggest the advantage it gains through this strategy is fairly meager. Further, while the captive agent channel still dominates results, the company has expanded into both the independent agent and direct channels in recent years. We don’t believe it has a meaningful advantage in these channels, and results have been generally disappointing.
We continue to believe that Allstate has a defensible position in its core captive agent channel. As customers add policies, they are more likely to rely on an agent who can help them customize their policies and save them money through bundling. Each additional policy will allow the customer to save money, as actuarial evidence shows these policyholders are lower risk, and each incremental policy creates stickier customers. Because these customers have multiple policies for a car (or two), a home, and possibly a boat, price shopping becomes more burdensome, making them less likely to switch companies to save a small amount on premiums. Whereas many of its competitors use independent agents to source sales, Allstate's captive agents sell only company policies. This allows Allstate to benefit from the stickiness of the customer relationship, rather than an independent agent.
Bull case
Allstate has historically had a differentiated approach through its use of captive agents and its bundling strategy.
The company has been increasing prices on many of its policies, which should lead to improved underlying profitability.
Allstate is benefiting from higher interest rates.
Bear case
Allstate's growth prospects are quite limited, given its dependence on the declining captive agent channel and the maturity of the insurance industry.
Despite reducing its exposure to some coastal areas, Allstate may experience large loss years caused by Midwestern catastrophes.
Autonomous cars could make auto insurance obsolete over time.
By Brett Horn, CFA
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:01:24 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Allstate discussion 0 comments