AutoNation
✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed
- Implied fair-value range of 95.20-186.45, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
- Current price is +24.6% above the average-multiple fair value of 140.82.
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Auto & Truck Dealerships
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AutoNation (AN) | 5.61B | 8.44 | 2.48 | 0.00% |
| Carvana (CVNA) | 46.15B | 30.70 | 10.60 | 0.00% |
| Penske Automotive (PAG) | 13.94B | 15.47 | 2.34 | 2.66% |
| CarMax (KMX) | 6.82B | 22.57 | 1.08 | 0.00% |
| Rush Enterprises-B (RUSHB) | 6.63B | 24.80 | 2.77 | 0.91% |
| Lithia Motors (LAD) | 6.21B | 8.28 | 0.94 | 0.83% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 35.6% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
AutoNation stock rose 6.1% Oct. 30 after reporting third-quarter adjusted diluted earnings per share of $5.11, beating the $5.08 LSEG consensus. CEO Mike Manley said share repurchases are likely to remain the preferred use of excess capital. 2026 buybacks are on pace to exceed 2025’s $785 million.
Why it matters: Share repurchases boosted adjusted diluted EPS by $0.64, so the 2% year-over-year EPS increase would be a 10.8% decline without $162.9 million in spending during the quarter. Manley’s comments suggest no acquisitions soon, but the firm closed on $600 million in annual revenue in June. AutoNation also announced its board approved buying back an additional $1 billion of stock, so $1.4 billion of authorization is available as of Oct. 28, about 24% of the Oct. 30 market capitalization. Given AutoNation’s long history of buybacks, we expect more authorizations over time. The tough comparison with third-quarter 2025 electric vehicle sales, as the tax credit expired last year, was a $0.52 EPS headwind this quarter. The 4.7% new vehicle same-store revenue decline contributed to an overall same-store decline of 2.4%. New vehicle inventory is still elevated, however.
The bottom line: We are leaving our narrow moat and $238 fair value estimate in place for AutoNation. We like the stock’s valuation and are glad to see management continuing to aggressively repurchase stock well below our fair value estimate. We think management is wisely building an AI ecosystem to boost the expense efficiency of its national brick-and-mortar store network. AI will lower back-office costs but also create opportunities to sell more service work, improving the ratio of overhead to gross profit. Total liquidity at Sept. 30 was $1.5 billion, including $1.4 billion on the credit line. In September, the line’s maturity was extended to September 2031 with a $2 billion limit, up from $1.9 billion. In October, the commercial paper capacity increased to $2 billion from $1.9 billion.
Fair value
Our AutoNation fair value estimate is $238 per share. Our weighted average cost of capital is 8.0%. Our midcycle operating margin, including floor plan interest expenses, is about 4%. Our midcycle operating margin reflects margins that we think can range from below 2.5% in bad times to at least the high 4s in good times. We do not consider 2021-23 levels of as much as over 7% to be maintainable, as new-vehicle pricing power has lessened following the end of the chip shortage.
We continue to see a healthy long-term growth runway as AutoNation is one of the largest players in what is still an extremely fragmented yet consolidating sector. We calculate that the adjusted operating margin, including floor plan interest expense, for 2022 was a record 7.4% and declined to 5.7% in 2023, 4.2% in 2024, and 4.3% in 2025. In our model, if we took operating margin, including floor plan interest, in the final two years of our five-year explicit forecast period, up to 4.5% in each year, our fair value estimate would be $273 per share. We believe that although the auto dealership industry is a good industry, it is still a cyclical one. However, we think AutoNation's size, brand, and digital storefront and shopping experience, AutoNation Express, will enable the company to continue driving market share gains and may provide enough selling, general, and administrative leverage for further meaningful margin expansion in good economic times. The Waymo service contract opens up a new channel for long-term revenue growth as well; AutoNation invested $50 million in Waymo in March 2020. The mobile service business started in 2023 with the RepairSmith (now called AutoNation Mobile Service) acquisition, which should also open new doors for growth, such as perhaps providing quality assurance for consumers selling their vehicle to another consumer.
We model a single-digit number of AutoNation USA stores opening through 2030, as management's enthusiasm for more stores has fallen off from a few years ago. AutoNation Finance, the captive finance arm, should provide meaningful profits several years from now once it scales up and was profitable for the first time in 2025 with $9.8 million pretax profit. Loan assets as of the end of the third quarter were about $2.8 billion, and management guides for these loans to be 2.5-3 times more profitable over their duration compared with traditional dealer reserve commissions. The captive issued its first asset-backed securitization sale in the second quarter of 2025 and its fifth will be in November. AutoNation Finance at the end of September was funded via 91% nonrecourse debt. Funding was via three warehouse lines, but in October two lines were closed and one syndicated $1.5 billion warehouse tied to SOFR now funds originations.
We believe the company's cost structure will enhance its scale benefits as vehicle sales volumes improve. We forecast revenue to grow at about a 4% rate on a five-year compound annual basis during our five-year forecast period, and the US new-vehicle share approaching 2% at the end of our five-year explicit forecast period. We expect operating margin, including floor plan interest expense, to average around 4.1% and capital expenditures to average 1.2% of sales. We model about $400 million-$500 million annually for cash paid for acquisitions (slightly less in 2026) and $400 million a year for share repurchases, though 2026 is modeled at $800 million given spending through Sept. 30 of $619.9 million at an average price of $199.97 per share.
Economic moat
We give AutoNation a Morningstar Economic Moat Rating of narrow, as its size continues to generate economies of scale and working-capital efficiencies while the service segment's warranty work gives the company an intangible advantage over garages. A large dealer such as AutoNation can move inventory among different stores within a market where it will be in greatest demand, something a small dealer with just one or two stores in that same market cannot do. We think the dealer sector is the best business in the automotive supply chain. Public dealers can centralize back-office operations and generate far more volume than small dealers, thereby bringing scale. Dealers have no burdensome retiree expenses, and the large public dealers are not dependent on the health of one brand. The dealers enjoy mid- to high-single-digit gross margins on new vehicles and 100% gross margins on financing and insurance. We think the best source of competitive advantage is the parts and service operations, commonly called "fixed ops" or in AutoNation's case "customer care". Many customers bring their vehicle to the dealer for service, either because the vehicle is under warranty or the dealer is close to home and has the factory parts and expertise to service the vehicle. Once vehicle owners know a dealer, we think they are likely to keep going back to the dealer for service. The dealer knows the vehicle, and comparison shopping for repair work is very time-consuming because the customer has to bring the vehicle to each shop to get a quote. These cost advantages and intangible advantages from service give dealers a moat.
These logistics create inelasticity of demand, which confers pricing power on the dealer and is a source of strong profits in good times and bad. In fact, during a downturn in new-vehicle sales, dealers generally report higher gross margins due to a favorable mix shift toward parts, but then report lower operating margins due to deleverage in selling, general, and administrative expenses. Excluding large impairment and restructuring charges, dealers can still report positive EBIT even in a severe recession. Although most dealerships are good businesses, we think the large publicly traded dealers are best positioned for growth since they can be the most flexible in changing brand mix and can more easily invest in omnichannel shopping capabilities. Many small-business owners are choosing to exit or sell because they cannot get the scale on a variety of expenses compared with large dealer groups or do not want to invest to have a large digital brand. AutoNation is one of the largest dealers in the US, yet has only about 1.6% new-vehicle market share. About 91% of dealer owners own between one and five stores per the National Automobile Dealers Association, so we see a long growth runway for consolidators such as AutoNation.
AutoNation may further its advantage over smaller dealers with its AutoNation Express initiative, which it started in December 2014. Thanks to an IT investment of over $100 million and a single established national AutoNation brand, customers can select a vehicle online with a price given online and reserve the vehicle with a credit card for 48 hours. The customer then comes to the store and takes a test drive. For a cash deal with no trade-in, the customer can leave in a new vehicle within 30 minutes. Small dealers also cannot have their own branded parts, which lowers AutoNation's reconditioning costs, nor can they get a nationwide service contract for an autonomous vehicle fleet, as AutoNation has with Waymo. The January 2023 acquisition of mobile service provider RepairSmith (later rebranded to AutoNation Mobile Service) also helps differentiate AutoNation from smaller dealer groups.
In 2015, AutoNation enhanced the Express program so that customers receive a trade-in offer online. After self-reporting the trade-in's condition, the customer can then fill out a loan application online and see loan offers, buy online finance and insurance products such as an extended warranty, and eventually be able to sign documents electronically at home to further reduce time in the store. Pricing on used vehicles is no-haggle. This type of project can only be completed by the largest dealers, who are well-capitalized through large credit lines and the capital markets. An omnichannel experience should also prove more attractive to millennial and Generation Z customers, who will also be searching online, where AutoNation is one of the few franchise dealers with something close to a national brand. It rebranded all 15 of its regional brands in 2013 as AutoNation and is investing in more advertising to enhance its brand equity and achieve reach that a small competitor could never have.
Bull case
AutoNation's massive size provides some appealing economies of scale, illustrated by strong operating margins.
AutoNation has been expanding its auto repair and used-vehicle operations, which generally carry higher margins and are less cyclical than new-car sales.
AutoNation Express makes the shopping experience far more attractive to consumers than shopping at most other dealers. AutoNation USA and the Waymo AV service deal add to the upside potential.
Bear case
About half of revenue is derived from new-car sales, leaving AutoNation vulnerable to the fluctuations of a viciously cyclical industry. This risk is greater for AutoNation as it gets a much larger share of its sales from California and Florida than the national average. These markets could be hit worse than other US markets in a housing downturn or by hurricanes.
Even the lucrative parts business often cannot wholly offset severe declines in new- and used-vehicle revenue.
Startup costs for AutoNation USA, the captive finance arm, and tech investments may compress margins for awhile.
By David Whiston, CFA, CPA, CFE
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:28 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
AutoNation discussion 0 comments