Expand Energy
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Oil & Gas E&P
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Expand Energy (EXE) | 18.77B | 7.01 | 0.96 | 2.83% |
| ConocoPhillips (COP) | 160.94B | 14.34 | 2.44 | 2.47% |
| Canadian Natural Resources (CNQ) | 90.32B | 9.40 | 2.76 | 3.90% |
| EOG Resources (EOG) | 77.05B | 9.59 | 2.33 | 2.75% |
| Occidental Petroleum (OXY) | 53.89B | 7.26 | 1.55 | 1.93% |
| Diamondback Energy (FANG) | 49.06B | 23.65 | 1.26 | 2.42% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 71.0% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Expand Energy reported adjusted EBITDA of $1.2 billion, in line with PitchBook consensus.
Why it matters: Management extended Appalachian curtailments into the fourth quarter, deferred wells, and demobilized two rigs. Gas prices remain weak, both in Appalachia and at Henry Hub. Robust supply growth and worries over a strong El Niño weigh on hopes for a winter rebound. In our conversation with the company, it's clear that the fundamentals are weak, and 2027 might see production decline below the 7.5 bcf/d midcycle target. This aligns with our expectations of producer behavior and recovery. Inflation pressures are likely to take hold in 2027 and are not isolated to any single item. Diesel is elevated, rigs can move to the oil patch, and everything from steel to tubing is likely to weigh on margins.
The bottom line: We are lowering our fair value estimate to $139 per share from $142 after incorporating the most recent results, increasing 2027 unit costs and fourth-quarter gas differentials, and reducing our 2027 production. Improved marketing revenue partially offset the decrease. We still see Expand as the most undervalued gas producer in our coverage, trading deep into 4-star territory. Our no-moat Morningstar Economic Moat, Standard Morningstar Capital Allocation, and High Morningstar Uncertainty Ratings remain unchanged.
Key stats: In our conversation, we got some more color on the Twin Eagle integration. Existing Twin Eagle customers have been increasing their commitments and extending them longer due to Expand's larger balance sheet. This supports a more consistent margin gain on the activity. The fourth quarter was guided to a 12 cent per thousand cubic feet margin improvement, but generally gas marketing is the most lucrative in the first quarter. Worth noting, too, is that when in-basin pricing is weak, marketing margins generally improve as they capture the delta between markets. For Expand, this provides a counterweight to the current environment.
Broadly, the results align with the case we laid out in our October Expand Energy Stock Pitch. Rigs are being demobilized and wells deferred as weak near-term fundamentals discourage new production, setting the stage for a recovery.
The Twin Eagle results are also encouraging. We hope to see further bolt-ons to the business, entering or expanding sales points to more fully realize the opportunity. These acquisitions will also be much cheaper to complete than some upstream assets.
The EQT-Range Resources merger announced this week is an obvious overhang. With a single deal, Expand lost both the largest producer and marketer crowns as EQT is confident it can convert the new volumes to structured sales. Large mergers and acquisitions in response at this moment would not be viewed favorably by us, as cheap producers are at best trading at a similar multiple to Expand. There are some targets in Appalachia, but doing so would likely be dilutive, as the balance sheet needs to be protected to execute the marketing strategy.
Analysts clearly remain skeptical of the pick of Danny Brown as CEO, as are we. His background of near pure upstream oil deviates substantially from Expand's strategy, putting him in the backseat to members of his team. On the bright side, that means experts steeped in commercial and midstream operations will likely run the show.
What he does offer is a record of successful upstream rollup execution and integration, which will have an important part to play in the medium term, just not today. Expand is the first- and second-largest holder of Tier 1 and 2 inventory in the Haynesville and Appalachia, respectively. However, only the Haynesville has a comfortable depth required to support long-term commercial agreements. Appalachia is ripe for further consolidation, as many small and medium operators will realize they lack the scale and quality to compete. Exits through sales to larger producers, or even to a consumer, will probably pick up over the next few years.
Fair value
We lowered our fair value estimate to $139 per share from $142. Weak local pricing in Appalachia, inflationary cost pressures, and reducing our 2027 production outlook all contributed to the decline. Successes in the new marketing business partially offset this, and we expect it to be a tailwind.
We assume oil (West Texas Intermediate) prices will average $86 and $83 per barrel in 2026 and 2027, respectively. In the same periods, natural gas (Henry Hub) prices are expected to average $3.12 and $3.36 per thousand cubic feet. Terminal prices are defined by our long-term midcycle price estimates (currently $65/bbl Brent, $60/bbl WTI, and $3.70/mcf natural gas).
Our fair value estimate corresponds to enterprise value/EBITDA multiples of 6.4 times and 6.6 times for 2026 and 2027, respectively. Our 2026 production forecast is 7,465 thousand cubic feet of natural gas equivalent per day (mmcfe/d), in line with management’s guidance. That drives 2026 EBITDA to $5.9 billion, and we expect free cash flow to reach $3.1 billion in the same period. Our 2027 estimates for production, EBITDA, and free cash flow are approximately 7,486 mmcfe/d, $5.7 billion, and $2.6 billion, respectively.
Economic moat
We assign Expand Energy a Morningstar Economic Moat Rating of none. Our assumed midcycle price of $3.70 per thousand cubic feet is insufficient to give us confidence that Expand could dependably return its cost of capital through the cycle. In upcycles, Expand generates substantial excess returns, but in downcycles, such as 2024, returns have gone negative.
For exploration and production firms, we assign moats based on the quality of acreage. High-quality acreage secures returns through the cycle by lowering breakeven per-molecule cost, allowing the producer to maintain or increase production without returns declining below the cost of capital, except in the most extreme cases. Of the oil producers who have moats, they produce returns in the low to midteens at midcycle prices.
Natural gas producers have an additional wrinkle with midstream capacity. Gas production is constrained by both demand and pipelines to deliver it to markets. It can only be moved economically in pipelines for overland travel. Without dedicated pipeline capacity to get volumes to demand markets, even prized acreage may be worth very little from a moat perspective.
We currently do not assign a moat to any natural gas producer. Seasonal demand, paired with insufficient pipeline capacity, leads to large price swings both day to day and location to location. Even for an Appalachian producer, discounts of 40% are not unheard of, as a cool summer or warm winter can drastically change demand on short cycles. Oil and NGLs are more easily transported and stored, suffering less from infrastructure and demand dislocation.
Additionally, natural gas-focused producers face competition from associated natural gas produced by oil-focused operations. Because gas is secondary, if it is even a concern, it sells at deep discounts. In recent years, natural gas has had a negative value in the Permian. Natural gas production from mature oil basins will continue to rise even if oil production stays flat, as older wells produce more gas as they age. If supply ever outstrips demand, natural gas-focused producers will be the first to restrain production, limiting their ability to earn a cost advantage moat.
Expand operates in the Haynesville, northeast Appalachia, and southwest Appalachia. Haynesville and northeast Appalachia are characterized as dry, producing only natural gas and no liquids. Together, these accounted for 78% of total production in the first half of 2025. Southwest Appalachia produced the remainder and is responsible for all of the company's oil and natural gas liquids.
The Haynesville basin can be viewed as the gas station for US LNG production, benefiting from both proximity and favorable regulatory frameworks. Louisiana, home to both the Haynesville basin and a massive concentration of US LNG export capacity, has always been friendly to oil and gas development. For that reason, building new intrastate pipelines connecting the basin to the Gulf Coast has been far easier than building interstate pipelines that connect producing regions to traditional natural gas consumers, such as population and industrial centers. As LNG production ramps up in Louisiana through 2030, natural gas produced in the Haynesville may receive a consistent premium to US benchmarks. On the other hand, producers and pipeline developers in Texas, Louisiana’s neighbor and noted oil and gas producer, see the same opportunity. LNG producers have also been developing their own pipeline infrastructure to capture gas before it reaches the local hubs, attempting to secure a discount upstream. Given the attractiveness of the opportunity, the favorable regulatory environment, and the proximity to other producing fields, we expect any premium to be eroded eventually.
Appalachia, on the other hand, will likely continue to receive a discount. The web of jurisdictions for the basin has limited new pipeline development, causing acute pipeline tightness and contributing to wide differentials and flat production growth. Most major producers have entered maintenance capacity plans to prevent the worst of overproduction. This pressure may ease as the breakneck data center cycle has identified the region as ripe for development because of its ample gas supply. Local infrastructure can serve any in-basin demand more easily, subject to far fewer regulatory conditions. This demand can serve two purposes: providing a way to increase production without worsening the in-basin discount or narrowing the discount with a constrained production plan.
For both the Haynesville and Appalachian basins, Expand’s strategy is only to produce to its pipeline capacity and is limited by in-basin demand. To that end, it has invested in and is an anchor shipper on the new NG3 pipeline connecting the Haynesville to the Gulf Coast.
Bull case
The Haynesville footprint will benefit materially from LNG expansions due to its proximity to them.
New power and data center demand in Appalachia and the Southeast will provide stable new demand sources for Expand to capitalize on.
Natural gas pricing in the US has substantial room to grow as domestic and export demand outruns oil production and associated natural gas production into the 2030s.
Bear case
Natural gas producers compete with oil producers, who throw off low-cost gas. Associated gas production is expected to continue growing as oilfields age and new pipelines are developed.
New infrastructure connecting production to demand will naturally constrain the growth of natural gas prices as producers seek to meet demand.
Ongoing elevated natural gas prices will erode demand, incentivizing the use of alternative power sources.
By Adam Baker
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:38 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Expand Energy discussion 0 comments