Skip to content

First Citizens BancShares

US · FCNCA #835 by market cap Listed 1970
2,075.52 -78.78 -3.66%
Periodic snapshot; not a real-time feed. · 2026-11-20 20:02

✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed

Near fair value
955.58 fair value ≈ 1,654.55 2,353.51
  • Implied fair-value range of 955.58-2,353.51, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
  • Current price is +25.4% above the average-multiple fair value of 1,654.55.

Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range

P/B ratio 1.18 In line with history 45th percentile
5-year average 1.29 · #183 of 352 in Banks - Regional
P/E ratio 10.66 In line with history 35th percentile
5-year average 10.01 · forward 10.23 · #107 of 311 in Banks - Regional
P/S ratio 2.46 Cheap vs history 11th percentile
5-year average 3.18 · forward 2.43 · #85 of 353 in Banks - Regional

Vs. peers Banks - Regional

Company Market cap P/E (TTM) P/B Div yield
First Citizens BancShares (FCNCA) 22.96B 10.66 1.18 0.40%
HDFC Bank (HDB) 140.70B 18.65 1.61 1.29%
ICICI Bank (IBN) 127.42B 20.33 3.04 0.70%
Mizuho Financial (MFG) 107.69B 11.96 1.65 1.03%
U.S. Bancorp (USB) 87.34B 10.88 1.46 3.75%
PNC Financial Services (PNC) 84.56B 11.35 1.36 3.33%

Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.

Morningstar

★★★★☆ Fair value2,540.00 Economic moatNone UncertaintyHigh Capital allocationExemplary

Trading 22.4% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.

Analyst note

First Citizens reported good third-quarter results, with net interest margin down 3 basis points from the prior quarter and net interest income up 2.6% sequentially thanks to strong average loan growth of 2.6%.

Why it matters: Interest-bearing deposit costs rose by 9 basis points sequentially, on the high end of regional peers under our coverage. The acquisition of BMO branches, closed on Sept. 4, added $4.9 billion in deposits at a weighted average cost of 1.05%. BMO branch deposit costs compare favorably with the overall bank's cost of deposits at 2.16% in the third quarter, indicating the legacy First Citizens' interest-bearing deposit costs rose higher than the reported number. We think the bank's guidance for fourth-quarter 2027 net interest margin in the mid-3.20s is quite lofty. The bank expects a deposit beta of 50% in this rate-hiking cycle, similar to the last hiking cycle, while we expect increasing consumer yield-seeking and the bank’s paydown of the FDIC purchase money note to push deposit beta higher.

The bottom line: As we incorporate the latest results and updated guidance, we don't expect to materially change our $2,430 fair value estimate for no-moat-rated First Citizens. We assess shares as fairly valued after a high-single-digit share price increase following today's earnings release. We expect 2027 full-year net interest margin around 3.14%, which is still an expansion from the third quarter 2026's 3.07%. First Citizens screens as the most asset-sensitive regional bank under our coverage, but higher deposit funding costs would offset part of the benefit from potential federal-funds rate hikes in the remainder of 2026 and in 2027.

Key stats: The bank expects to fully repay the remaining $20.5 billion of 3.5% fixed-rate FDIC borrowings by the end of 2027. As of September 2026, the bank has paid down $15.5 billion of the $36 billion original balance.

Management still expects to pay down the 3.5% fixed-rate FDIC purchase money note using both excess liquidity and potential issuance of debt. Our base case forecast does not include inorganic deposit growth from branch acquisitions or whole-bank purchases, and we expect the excess liquidity to mostly come from the growth of direct bank and brokered deposit balances, which are both relatively expensive funding sources compared with branch deposits, on top of the general higher deposit competition in the banking industry that we forecast.

Fair value

We are raising our fair value estimate to $2,540 per share from $2,430. Around $30 of the increase is from the time value of money; the remaining $80 comes from higher net interest income growth in the near term and lower 2026 credit costs. First Citizens is one of the most rate-sensitive regional banks under our coverage, though higher funding costs will partly offset the positive impact of higher interest rates. We expect the bank to increase its net interest income at a compound annual growth rate of 2.9% from 2025 to 2030. Our fair value estimate is equivalent to 1.5 times tangible book value as of Sept. 30, 2026. We assume an 8.9% cost of equity.

Consistent with other banks, growth in net interest income, driven by changes in the net interest margin and balance sheet growth, growth in fee-based income, and operating expenses are the key valuation drivers.

After adjusting for the rental income from its small, noncore railcar leasing business, First Citizens derives around 80% of its revenue from net interest income. The bank’s NII has many different moving parts. Following the 2022 acquisition of CIT Group and the 2023 acquisition of Silicon Valley Bridge Bank, net interest margin skewed higher by purchase accounting accretion from 2022 to 2025. We expect its 2026 adjusted NIM, excluding PAA, to be about 3.01%, with unadjusted NIM at about 3.09%. For 2026, the bank is also paying down some portion of its $33 billion fixed-rate 3.5% borrowings from the FDIC (related to the SVBB acquisition) due in 2028, and replacing the funding mostly with excess liquidity on its balance sheet. We forecast around 13.5% growth in deposits in 2026, and we expect the bank to continue growing its direct bank segment deposits (higher-cost online deposits) at a faster pace than its branch deposits, which would also put some pressure on deposit costs in 2026. Marrying these levers, we forecast a decline of 1.6% in 2026 NII, following a 4.6% decline in 2025. We expect around 7.1% growth in net interest income in 2027, driven by both loan growth and net interest margin expansion by around 5 basis points.

Longer term, we project First Citizens’ net interest margin to normalize around 3.11%, which reflects our expectation of an upward-sloping yield curve. We expect the bank to grow its loans at a CAGR of 3.5% from 2025 to 2035. This results in an NII CAGR of 3.0%.

On the fee-income side, we forecast around 5.7% growth in 2026, excluding rental income from railcar leasing and gain on sale of equipment. We expect normalized adjusted fee income (excluding rental leasing income) growth of around 3.7% for the bank in the long run.

We forecast adjusted expense growth of about 3.9% in 2026, excluding railcar leasing-related expenses and other noncore expenses. While this represents a slowdown from the 8.0% growth in 2025 and 16% growth in 2024, expenses remain elevated due to ongoing investment in risk management and control systems. Over time, we expect the bank’s adjusted efficiency ratio (excluding the rental business and other noncore expenses) to normalize around 59.7%. Although this falls well short of management’s mid-50s, it's still an improvement from its past decade average of around 61.7%.

For its railcar leasing business, which accounts for less than 5% of its earnings, we expect the bank’s net rental income from railcar leasing (after adjusting for depreciation and maintenance expenses) to grow at a CAGR of 3.3% from 2025 to 2035.

Finally, we forecast First Citizens’ 2026 net charge-off ratio at 0.29%, down from 0.44% in 2025. We expect the bank’s net charge-off ratio to normalize around 0.41% through the cycle, which is higher than legacy First Citizens levels, reflecting higher credit costs associated with SVB and CIT Group. Overall, we expect an average return on tangible common equity of 12.0% over the next 10 years, higher than our 8.9% cost of equity estimate for the firm.

Economic moat

We assign First Citizens a Morningstar Economic Moat Rating of none because we do not believe it has durable cost advantages consistent with our bank moat framework. While we think the bank’s record of acquiring troubled banks is impressive, we do not believe this alone constitutes a moat. While we forecast the bank to generate returns on tangible equity in the low teens on a normalized basis, the spread is thin when compared with its 8.9% cost of equity, and we are not confident enough that the bank can consistently outearn its COE over the 10-year time horizon that would be suggestive of a narrow moat rating. We would like to see further improvement in funding costs and operating efficiency, as well as the development of more robust fee income businesses, before considering a Narrow Moat Rating for First Citizens.

We believe bank moats are derived primarily from two sources: cost advantages and switching costs. We see cost advantages stemming from three primary factors: a low-cost funding base, excellent operating efficiency, and conservative underwriting. Regulatory costs must also be considered.

We don’t think First Citizens has a funding cost advantage because of the two large acquisitions it made over the past five years. First Citizens quadrupled its asset size between its 2022 acquisition of CIT Group and its 2023 acquisition of Silicon Valley Bridge Bank, but neither independently boasted a significant base of low-cost deposits. CIT Group lacked strong retail deposit-gathering capabilities, as evidenced by around 70% of its deposits from brokered and online deposits (two of the most expensive deposit sources) in the fourth quarter of 2020. Silicon Valley Bank saw deposit costs rise sharply after the acquisition (despite First Citizens stabilizing deposit outflows within months) as noninterest-bearing deposits shifted into interest-bearing accounts and rates on those accounts increased. The bank is also actively growing more expensive online deposits to replace its FDIC fixed-rate borrowings. As a result, First Citizens' deposit funding costs are the highest among our regional bank coverage. We do not believe First Citizens has a funding cost advantage, which matters, given that the bank derives between 75% and 80% of its adjusted revenue from net interest income.

We also don’t view First Citizens as being advantaged in operating efficiency. Its adjusted operating efficiency ratio (excluding railcar leasing and acquisition gains) was impressive in 2023 and 2024, in the high 50s (lower is better), but most of this reflects robust net interest income, buoyed by the rate environment and purchase accounting marks. We estimate its adjusted normalized operating efficiency ratio is likely around 60%, more in line with no-moat regional bank peers, though still an improvement from its historical high-60s average. Weak fee income and suboptimal deposit market share in its core markets, despite improved scale from recent acquisitions, explain much of this disadvantage. First Citizens' 2025 adjusted fee income (excluding railcar leasing) represented only 19% of revenue, well below the typical moaty regional banks' 30%-plus mix. It has attractive fee-income products, including wealth management, merchant fees, and deposit service fees, but we don't expect these to grow much faster than its balance sheet. It also holds top deposit share in only a few markets, making it harder to spread its largely fixed branch-network costs. Excluding the $48 billion in online deposits (30% of its deposit base) booked in Raleigh, the bank derived around 23% of deposits from North Carolina (ranks fourth excluding online deposits), 8% from South Carolina (also fourth), and 31% from California (seventh), per FDIC data as of June 2025. Moaty peers typically derive most deposits from a top-five local market share.

On credit costs, we think First Citizens has a strong underwriting culture. While the bank made two large, transformational acquisitions that may have diluted some of its edge, we believe the management team can institutionalize its strong underwriting culture and that the bank will remain a solid performer on credit costs.

Regulatory costs matter at the industry level and for First Citizens specifically. The US banking system has improved over the last decade, with capital levels at all-time highs and stronger postcrisis regulation. Despite intense competition, the largest banks by assets have earned higher returns on equity for decades and still do. Our long-run outlook is positive, given the US' stable democracy, steady GDP growth, and reserve currency status.

First Citizens is not large enough to be a global systemically important bank and avoids some of the more burdensome regulatory requirements. It is currently a Category IV bank, subject to the Federal Reserve's stress test every two years, with 2026 being its first year facing the test. Management has been investing in risk management, including Category III-related spending. Category III requirements trigger if assets exceed $250 billion (our expectation is around 2028), subjecting the bank to annual stress tests, liquidity coverage requirements, and the supplementary leverage ratio. It should manage this transition well. The March 2026 Basel III endgame proposal and 2025 stress test changes are mostly positive for First Citizens. The key change for banks with between $100 billion and $700 billion in assets is including accumulated other comprehensive income in common equity Tier 1 capital, which First Citizens should handle well: It carried small negative AOCI marks as of Sept. 30, 2026, and had a common equity Tier 1 ratio of 10.2% as of June 30, 2026, well above its 7% regulatory minimum.

Bull case

First Citizens' California and Southeast footprint has attractive growth potential. If the bank successfully gains more deposit market share, it can improve its funding and return profile.

The bank could see higher balance sheet growth from its early- and growth-stage clients if more private equity and venture capital dry powder is put to work.

If the bank can bring more of the legacy SVB clients’ money back to its platform, it could see more balance sheet growth or even growth in wealth management fee income.

Bear case

In a recession, the bank would face slower balance sheet growth and higher credit costs.

First Citizens derives around 80% of revenue from net interest income. Its NII is very sensitive to changes in short-term rates, which puts it under great pressure if the Federal Reserve has to cut rates aggressively.

As of Sept. 30, 2026, the bank has about $20.5 billion in fixed-rate debt (3.5% rate) due in 2028. If the bank has to issue long-term debt to replace that funding at a significantly higher rate, its net interest margin could compress further.

By Maoyuan Chen

Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:25 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.

First Citizens BancShares discussion 0 comments

Add a comment