Johnson Controls
✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed
- Implied fair-value range of 108.91-156.90, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
- Current price is -2.1% below the average-multiple fair value of 132.91.
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Building Products & Equipment
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Johnson Controls (JCI) | 78.13B | 27.82 | 5.74 | 1.23% |
| Trane Technologies (TT) | 84.56B | 27.28 | 9.28 | 1.06% |
| Carrier Global (CARR) | 40.88B | -23.02 | 4.07 | 1.89% |
| Masco (MAS) | 15.92B | 17.92 | -35.54 | 1.54% |
| Carlisle Companies (CSL) | 14.64B | 21.42 | 10.18 | 1.20% |
| Madison Air Solutions Corp (MAIR) | 13.03B | 64.36 | 2.18 | 0.00% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 9.8% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Johnson Controls posted a strong end to the year with 12% organic sales growth to $7.1 billion and 32% growth in adjusted earnings per share to $1.66. Orders grew 44% and backlog grew 43% to $23 billion, which sets up the company for accelerating growth into fiscal 2027.
Why it matters: Unsurprisingly, results were strongest in the Americas (+14%) and APAC (+12%). Data centers drive the most growth, but other verticals (semiconductors, pharma, and so on) also contributed nicely. The company has done an impressive job expanding its total addressable market in the data center by offering cooling distribution units (CDUs) and cold plates, in addition to its core chiller systems. The company announced $400 million of restructuring expenses expected to generate $600 million of savings by 2029 by focusing on streamlining the less mission-critical and data center-oriented parts of the business, which presumably refers to the fire and security business.
Long view: We were reassured by management’s discussion that air-based cooling tech (namely chillers) is not likely to be displaced in data center designs for the foreseeable future, and the firm is regardless investing prudently in liquid-based cooling technologies to keep up with the latest trends in artificial intelligence. Management highlighted that even though most of the backlog could convert to revenue within 12 months, 2027 guidance (11%-12% organic growth), it anticipates more like 70%-80% conversion due to potential bottlenecks for customers based on power and electrical equipment.
The bottom line: We are increasing our fair value estimate for narrow-moat Johnson Controls to $143 per share from $129 based on increases in the firm’s guidance, which is well supported by backlog to deliver double-digit growth into at least 2027 and 2028. We also note that management guided to $900 million of capital expenditures (nearly double last year’s figure) to expand capacity and keep up with the latest technologies.
Fair value
Our $143 fair value estimate equates to about 22 times our 2027 earnings per share estimate of approximately $6.36, which is reasonable in historical context.
Management is guiding to accelerating growth in fiscal 2027 on improving backlogs, especially in data centers, a dynamic being observed across the peer group. Having reshaped the portfolio to focus on global HVAC and building automation, management is now targeting accelerating top-line growth in the low-double-digits to high-single-digits range and margin expansion driven by low-single-digit underlying market growth, improving product mix, and increased aftermarket/services penetration. HVAC is growing substantially faster than building automation, resulting in a growth profile somewhat lower than peers.
We model approximately a 9% revenue compound annual growth rate with approximately 50 basis points per year of margin improvement to 23%, which foots with peer group commentary and greater than 30% incremental margins on sales. Given the various corporate actions taken to focus the business, now is the time for management to execute, especially with regard to aftermarket attach rates and margin expansion. Given the CEO’s record of success elsewhere and evidence of similar performance across the peer group, we find these estimates to be credible.
With modest capital expenditures at 2% of sales and research and development likely comparable, we anticipate Johnson Controls to generate healthy free cash flow, which should expand its optionality.
Our stage two forecast period incorporates an estimated investment rate of 25% and earnings before interest growth rate of 6.5% with perpetual growth of 3%. An 8.7% weighted average cost of capital derives from a market-average cost of equity and the firm’s current capital structure.
Economic moat
We assign Johnson Controls a Narrow Morningstar Economic Moat Rating, supported by intangible assets and customer switching costs across its commercial HVAC and fire/security activities, which represent 60% and 40% of sales, respectively. There are relatively few companies in the commercial buildings HVAC space, and the market for large, complex HVAC systems (known as applied HVAC systems) is the most consolidated, especially in the United States. Four players—Trane, Johnson Controls, Carrier, and Daikin—essentially control the US applied HVAC market. Commercial HVAC competition on a global scale is more competitive, especially in Asian markets, where Daikin, Midea, and Gree are meaningful competitors. However, those firms focus more on ductless residential systems.
Johnson Controls’ technological know-how and service capabilities are key differentiators in commercial HVAC, especially for large, complex projects in which engineers tend to provide the sales/service as opposed to contractors who install residential solutions. Over the years, these differentiators have allowed the firm to build a large installed base, which can have long useful lives (up to 40 years for applied HVAC systems). An installed base of commercial HVAC systems is an important asset that can generate recurring revenue over the lifetime of the installed system and is priced at several multiples of the initial product sale. Given the mission-critical nature of commercial building systems, maintenance, service, and aftermarket parts are needed to avoid disruptive and costly system breakdowns.
We believe Johnson Controls’ Metasys and OpenBlue building automation platforms set the company apart from its closest HVAC peers Carrier (Lynx) and Trane (Tracer). These platforms generate recurring software upgrades and subscription-based revenue. Perhaps more importantly, Johnson Controls’ building automation solutions can strengthen its value proposition to customers. Though revenue and market share aren’t disclosed, it would appear Johnson Controls at least enjoys a first winner advantage with this solution, and it likely enhances customer stickiness.
New commercial HVAC systems require significant upfront investment and installation time but have long lifecycles. As such, we believe building operators would be reluctant to completely replace entire systems and instead prefer to retrofit existing systems to adapt to changing technology, regulatory standards, and user requirements. This is a favorable dynamic for Johnson Controls, which is well positioned to capture incremental retrofit revenue in addition to unplanned service and routine maintenance revenue.
That said, the ability to capture future service revenue from an installed base is not guaranteed, especially for less sophisticated systems. We believe third-party service companies can generally service many commercial HVAC products, and some customers have internal engineers who can service systems to a certain extent. However, third-party or internal service engineers would still need to purchase aftermarket parts from the incumbent manufacturer for many projects.
With the Tyco merger in 2016, Johnson Controls added a large installed base of fire suppression and detection, access control, and electronic surveillance systems. Before the merger, Tyco’s approximate revenue mix was 20% products, 40% installation, and 40% service (monitoring, preventative maintenance, repair, and upgrades). Tyco management estimated that roughly 65% of service revenue was recurring (or 25% of total revenue). The global fire and security market is very fragmented. We believe Johnson Controls is the market leader with low-double-digit to midteens market share. Honeywell is its closest and largest fire and security rival. In our view, Johnson Controls’ portfolio of well-known fire and security brands, product breadth, system design, installation, and service capabilities and global scale are key differentiators that have helped build lasting relationships with key decision-makers, such as engineering and construction firms and building owners. Furthermore, we think Johnson Controls’ fire and security installed base is quite sticky, with the firm likely to secure contracts for system upgrades and expansion.
Few of Johnson Controls' competitors offer such a comprehensive suite of commercial building systems and related services. As such, there are few alternatives for building operators that value Johnson Controls' one-stop-shop approach and prefer to use one firm's equipment and services for its key building systems.
Johnson Controls operates an extensive branch network to provide installation and services for its customers around the globe. While myriad HVAC and fire and security service providers exist, few have the revenue base to support a similar-size branch network. As such, Johnson Controls is much better positioned to directly service customers that have multiple locations across the US and the world compared with local and regional competitors that don't have the scale to profitably service customers with national or multinational footprints. Furthermore, we believe Johnson Controls' branch density results in better service quality.
Bull case
Johnson Controls could achieve more-dominant share, especially in commercial solutions, widening its gap with Trane and Carrier.
Services/aftermarket attach rates could grow above management’s double-digit target and further enhance returns.
Having reshaped the portfolio, management may demonstrate greater capital allocation discipline.
Bear case
Pricing power could erode due to insufficient product differentiation.
Independent third parties might capture more of the aftermarket/service opportunity.
Returns could deteriorate from lack of focus at fire and security, or Johnson exits that business, reducing scale advantages.
By George Maglares
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:29 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Johnson Controls discussion 0 comments