Skip to content

Mattel

US · MAT #2238 by market cap Listed 2009
13.71 -0.69 -4.79%
Periodic snapshot; not a real-time feed. · 2026-11-20 19:33

✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed

Near fair value
3.01 fair value ≈ 23.06 43.11
  • Implied fair-value range of 3.01-43.11, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
  • Current price is -40.5% below the average-multiple fair value of 23.06.

Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range

P/B ratio 1.84 Cheap vs history 1st percentile
5-year average 3.31 · #11 of 22 in Leisure
P/E ratio 8.95 Cheap vs history 13th percentile
5-year average 18.60 · forward 12.28 · #1 of 16 in Leisure
P/S ratio 0.78 Cheap vs history 5th percentile
5-year average 1.18 · forward 0.75 · #9 of 29 in Leisure

Vs. peers Leisure

Company Market cap P/E (TTM) P/B Div yield
Mattel (MAT) 3.91B 8.11 1.67 0.00%
Amer Sports (AS) 16.45B 25.47 2.30 0.00%
Hasbro (HAS) 15.72B 16.75 17.21 2.49%
Life Time (LTH) 10.41B 25.04 3.01 0.00%
Acushnet Holdings (GOLF) 4.58B 21.63 5.28 1.25%
Planet Fitness (PLNT) 4.37B 20.04 -7.18 0.00%

Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.

Morningstar

★★★★☆ Fair value22.50 Economic moatNarrow UncertaintyHigh Capital allocationStandard

Trading 64.1% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.

Analyst note

Mattel's third quarter included sales growth of 4%, to $1.8 billion, aided by global gross billings growth of 9% in vehicles and 12% in challenger segments. Adjusted operating margin expanded 480 basis points, to 55%, primarily due to $88 million in tariff refunds (flat excluding tariff payback).

Why it matters: Excluding tariff returns, Mattel lowered its 2026 EPS outlook to $1.05-$1.20 from $1.27-$1.29 prior. This is a result of new management radioing caution given softer recent point of sale trends that decelerated late in the third quarter and persisted into the current quarter. In turn, Mattel's 2026 sales are now expected to rise 1%-4% versus 3%-6% prior and the gross margin is forecast at 48% (versus 50% prior), implying only modest expansion (50-100 basis points) in the fourth quarter. This is about 300 basis points worse than our prior forecast. A bright point was in the consistent geographic sales, indicating the brands are resonating with consumers and the intangible asset remains intact. North America and international sales rose 4% and 5%, respectively.

The bottom line: We plan to lower our $23 per share fair value estimate for narrow-moat Mattel by a mid-single-digit rate due to weaker near-term demand. Still, we view shares as attractive after assessing its normalized earnings power rather than the depressed current performance. Although new management didn't reiterate the prior 2027 outlook for mid- to high-single-digit sales and double-digit operating income growth, our prior 2027 forecast included sales growth of 2.5% and operating income growth of 14.5%, which renders a still subdued 11% operating margin. We think the CEO's goals to strengthen brands and win in toys, drive innovation, and invest to realize profitable growth are fundamentally sound and could put Mattel back on track to 13% terminal operating margins. Still, this has been tried before, and as such, remains a show-me story.

From an investor perspective, the current year has been filled with noise around Mattel's weak stock performance, with shareholders including Southeastern Asset Management, Ariel Investments, and EdgePoint Investment Group pushing for change. Given that shares have fallen 30% over the past five years, options presented have included seeking a financial buyer to selling parts of the business to improve profitability. We believe such suggestions resulted in the firm's appointment of Roger Lynch as CEO, Peter Griffith as CFO, and the election of Lee Matheson, a partner at EdgePoint, to the board of directors. While we are pleased to see new leadership brought on to affect change, we think surfacing quantitative proof from implemented updates will still take a year or more, limiting a near-term catalyst for shares.

Fair value

We are lowering our fair value estimate per share for Mattel to $22.50 from $23.00 to account for its third-quarter results and softer recent point-of-sale trends. The firm's sales rose by 4% in the third quarter, aided by gross billings of vehicles (up 9%) and challenger categories (up 12%). Still, costs (tariffs, inflation, and investments) added pressure to profitability, but a tariff refund led to an adjusted operating margin expansion of more than 500 basis points (27.8%). Additionally, the operating profit outlook for 2026 of $500 million to $570 million implies a second consecutive year of operating margin contraction. On the top line, Mattel’s 2026 guidance for an increase of 1%-4% in constant currency (with foreign exchange anticipated to have a 1% benefit) was lowered (from 3%-6%), and our forecast is for 4% growth, to $5.5 billion, near the roughly $5.4 billion in sales the firm delivered over the last five consecutive years. While macroeconomic and political uncertainty will provide continued volatility, we don’t think consumer spending hesitancy will persist indefinitely. As consumers return to spending when sentiment stabilizes, we see no reason Mattel’s portfolio of brands shouldn’t be in demand.

The traditional toy industry remains mature and stable, and global demand is expected to grow at 3.6% on average through 2030, according to Euromonitor. Mattel should be able to largely maintain its global market share, as product improvements and growth in emerging markets should bolster moderate domestic growth. The firm should also gain licensing traction from its entertainment tie-ups, including Disney Princess (resumed in 2023), Despicable Me, KPop Demon Hunters, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Pokémon, and Lightyear licenses. We project around 2.2% sales growth over our forecast, weighed down by weak performance in the infant, toddler and preschool business. We forecast that selling and administrative expenses will benefit from continued cost savings (ending around 27.6%), although this will be offset by ongoing investment in product innovation to bolster its competitive edge, secure its leadership position, and its narrow economic moat. Furthermore, we see the advertising spending ratio remaining around 10% as the company invests in connecting with consumers.

We believe Mattel's operating margins and returns on invested capital should generally rise as the Optimizing for Profitable Growth initiative continues to bear fruit. We forecast operating margins that average 12.2%, constrained by investments in innovation, inflation, and tariffs, which a more favorable consumer sentiment could mitigate. Mattel has historically generated ROICs above our weighted average cost of capital assumption (8%), and we believe it could continue to produce compelling ROICs as it redevelops brand enthusiasm. With Mattel having shuttered some of its manufacturing, ROICs, including goodwill, should average 15% over the next decade.

Economic moat

We assign a narrow Morningstar Economic Moat Rating to Mattel stemming from an intangible asset edge arising from its long-lived brands that have consistently resounded with customers, the ability to market its products effectively, and an engrained distribution network. This has surfaced in robust market share, historically stable pricing power, the skill to win licensing partnerships, and symbiotic wholesaler/retailer relationships.

We think Mattel’s aptitude to amass a significant presence indicates its brands have been able to evolve with consumer trends, particularly on its home turf, where it has remained a leading operator for decades. For example, in the $3.1 billion toddler infant preschool market (just 15% of its North American sales mix), Mattel is the number-one player with a 26% share of the baby/infant market, more than double the level of its nearest competitor, and the number-one player in the preschool market with 30% market share bolstered by well-known brands like Fisher-Price and Thomas (Euromonitor). Additionally, Mattel has amassed a solid standing in the $5.1 billion doll and $1.3 billion vehicle market domestically, where it represents 27% and 72%, respectively, of the aisle, which together represent 47% of the firm’s gross sales base. While the global stage is more fragmented, Mattel still leads in market share across baby and infant (14%), dolls (24%), and vehicles (43%), categories that represent more than 80% of Mattel’s international sales composition. In our opinion, a strong market share implies brand relevance. In turn, we think Mattel’s in-demand products have allowed the firm to take pricing strategically.

Furthermore, when prior CEO Ynon Kreiz filled the seat in 2018, a sea change incorporating stability infiltrated the firm’s culture, with efforts on simplifying the business, monetizing the intellectual property, and focusing on the brands with the highest return on investment. The success of an updated strategic plan surfaced in Mattel's gross margin, which climbed from 40% in 2018 to 48.9% in 2025, despite facing inflationary pressures (plastic and resin costs increased 18% during 2019-25). Still, we see an opportunity for Mattel to further beef up gross margins from current levels. To start, the Optimizing for Profitable Growth initiative (2024-26) is slated to focus 55% of its $225 million total savings on benefiting the gross margin line. Additionally, Mattel has been able to tactically take price increases over the course of the last few years. As the new management led by Roger Lynch focuses on strengthening brands and winning in toys, driving innovation, and investing to realize profitable growth, we see gross margins stabilizing above 50% over the longer term, after reaching 48% in 2026 (excluding tariffs).

We believe Mattel’s ability to achieve an attractive market share and optimal pricing is due to consistent spending on product development, marketing, and advertising. Mattel’s product development costs are embedded within the selling, general, and administrative ratio, which has remained in a fairly consistent range over the last decade (mid- to high-20%). In our opinion, investing in product innovation is just as important for driving brand sales as advertising and promotional efforts. Mattel has also recognized this, allocating 10% of sales to these expenses on average over the last five years.

Moreover, not only does Mattel have several topnotch owned brands, but its position as one of the largest toy companies allows it to capture licensing partnerships with relative ease, as it is a top choice for any partner to pair with, with wide reach and deep marketing pockets. In recent years, Mattel has captured coveted contracts to produce toys for Disney Princess and Frozen, Pixar, Warner Bros., and Microsoft (Minecraft, Halo), brands that have shown long-term resonance with consumers. As such, industry leaders’ success in licensing partnerships has deterred new competitors from entering the market. The firm’s proven sales record maintains its dominance in securing new licensing deals, a trend unlikely to revert soon.

Additionally, we think Mattel’s established position with retailers has led to an interdependent relationship that would be hard to replicate by a new competitor, bolstering its brand edge. Mattel is an important vendor to companies like wide-moats Walmart and Amazon, as well as no-moat Target. In 2025, these three sellers represented 42% of worldwide consolidated net sales for Mattel, implying the importance of Mattel as a key supplier for filling the toy aisle. We don’t forecast these distribution partnerships to be disturbed, given that most peers in the industry are significantly smaller than Mattel’s $5.3 billion in net sales (2025) and unable to provide enough inventory to optimize shelf space (for example, a company like Spin Master that owns brands like Melissa & Doug sold $2.1 billion in toys in 2025).

Although Mattel holds a brand intangible asset edge, we don’t believe there is enough evidence to signal that it has developed a cost advantage, although expense metrics should improve modestly over time. For one, the cost savings from the firm’s prior pivot to more third-party production mirror how the peer set (Hasbro and Spin Master) already operated. Additionally, efforts to drive volume demand through a greater focus on better return on investment efforts (digital, direct to consumer, for example) while de-emphasizing underperforming stock-keeping units is a best practice for success, in our opinion, rather than an effort that Mattel has cornered. Furthermore, we consider the firm’s perpetual cost-saving initiatives—most recently, the $225 million Optimizing for Profitable Growth program—a function of a business that needed to improve efficiencies and invest in innovation rather than an effort that will set the cost profile of Mattel apart from its peers.

Bull case

Mattel's size allows it to fund new products, expand into high-growth emerging markets, and make acquisitions, while its portfolio of brands lends itself to scalable expansion in new categories like digital and new franchises.

As one of the largest players in the toy industry, Mattel is a preferred licensing partner for important tie-ins with entertainment brands.

Mattel's prior cost-saving and capital-light initiatives yielded $1 billion in run-rate savings. Efforts beyond the $225 million expected from the Optimizing for Profitable Growth initiative could reduce expenses further.

Bear case

The target market for traditional toys could continue to shrink as a percentage of total toy sales, hurt by digital content that becomes more pervasive in product selection.

Supply chain congestion, geopolitical disruptions, and inflationary headwinds could prevent Mattel from reaching midteen operating margins until beyond our forecast.

Mattel's inability to tailor its brands to digital content channels that increasingly resonate with consumers could lead to less brand relevance and slower sales growth than we currently anticipate.

By Jaime M. Katz, CFA

Quote time 2026-11-20 19:33:08 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.

Mattel discussion 0 comments

Add a comment