MSCI Inc
✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed
- Implied fair-value range of 524.47-798.54, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
- Current price is -7.7% below the average-multiple fair value of 661.51.
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Financial Data & Stock Exchanges
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MSCI Inc (MSCI) | 43.65B | 32.28 | -14.47 | 1.30% |
| S&P Global (SPGI) | 127.43B | 26.13 | 6.47 | 0.88% |
| CME Group (CME) | 110.09B | 25.21 | 4.14 | 3.67% |
| Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) | 95.01B | 23.16 | 3.18 | 1.20% |
| Moody's (MCO) | 80.49B | 28.48 | 24.63 | 0.86% |
| Nasdaq (NDAQ) | 57.12B | 28.12 | 4.76 | 1.13% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 0.1% above Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
MSCI’s organic revenue grew 12% in the third quarter. Net new subscription sales (net bookings) were $55 million versus $39 million in the year-ago quarter. Shares rose 5% in intraday trading.
Why It Matters: Aside from Sustainability and Climate, which represented about 7% of the firm’s profit, sales momentum was impressive across all other business lines. Trailing 12-month recurring subscription sales reached $207 million, up from $191 million at the end of the second quarter, representing 9% of its year-ago subscription run rate. We’re also encouraged that the firm’s asset-based fee rate on exchange-traded funds, which clocked in at 2.28 basis points on a run-rate basis, was steady. The metric ended 2025 at 2.41 basis points, stepped down to 2.35 basis points by the end of the first quarter due to a BlackRock renegotiation, and fell to 2.28 basis points by the end of the second quarter due to mix shifts and new asset tiers being hit from flows and market appreciation. As the firm invests in new products, management signaled little to no future margin expansion. While MSCI did not provide a specific timeline, its commentary suggested this would apply over a longer time horizon. Given the firm’s sales growth, we believe this strategy is warranted.
The bottom line: We will maintain our fair value estimate of $610 on wide-moat-rated MSCI. While results were strong, sales volumes can be lumpy. Though asset-based fee rates came in above our model, we also expect to model more tempered margin expansion. Net new subscription sales were supported by strong gross sales and continued strength in retention. The firm’s overall retention rate increased to 95.0% from 94.7% a year ago, with the high-profit index segment rising to 97.1% from 95.8%
Looking more closely at expenses, adjusted EBITDA expenses rose 13% year-over-year in the third quarter to $337 million, and the firm expects full-year adjusted EBITDA expenses to be at the high end of its $1.34 billion-$1.37 billion range. Adjusted EBITDA expenses were $1.23 billion in 2025, which implies a $140 million increase at the high end. Some year-over-year drivers include tuck-in acquisitions adding $20 million in additional expenses, $15 to 20 million in higher stock-based compensation from strong year-to-date results, and an additional $10 million-$15 million in severance costs from AI efficiencies (note: MSCI does not exclude severance expenses from adjusted results). Headcount was up only 0.1% year over year, and with 71% of the firm’s workforce in emerging markets, we see geographic optimization as a very limited lever at this point. We believe the remaining gap reflects broader inflation and higher technology spending.
Speaking generally about the future, MSCI expects little to no margin expansion (0 to 50 basis points) as it continues to invest in its growth opportunities. Given that MSCI earns high returns on invested capital, we believe this is an appropriate strategy. For existing businesses, MSCI expects AI-enabled efficiencies to slow expense growth from mid- to high-single-digit percentages to low-single-digit percentages, and eventually to outright declines. These savings will be redeployed toward new opportunities.
Hedge funds continue to be a standout, with roughly 18% subscription growth. One negative is that hedge funds tend to shut down more than other client segments in downturns. MSCI is seeing double-digit growth with asset owners and wealth managers, particularly as the total portfolio approach gains steam. Wealth management represents only 4% of the firm’s subscription run rate, so MSCI likely has a large opportunity there. By our math, the asset manager subscription run rate (45% of client mix) grew roughly 6% to 7%, which reflects the firm’s high penetration in that segment.
In addition to analytics and index, private assets also posted strong subscription sales, led by private capital solutions (Burgiss), which expanded to a subscription run rate of $147 million, up from $139 million at the end of the second quarter and $124 million a year ago, as institutional investors seek more data on private investments. Real estate remained weak, likely due to constrained end markets.
Sustainability and Climate remains a weak spot, with just 2% organic growth, and management expects sales trends to remain soft in the fourth quarter. That said, the firm acquired First Street, a provider of physics-based climate risk data and analytics, for $123 million during the quarter. This suggests that management views the headwinds in the segment as temporary.
For our latest long-form research, clients can view our Sept. 18 special report, "Information Services: How Many Jobs Can Move Offshore?"
Fair value
After updating our model following the firm’s release of third-quarter 2026 financial results, we are maintaining our fair value estimate of $610 as sales momentum is offset by lowering our margin expansion assumptions.
Our fair value estimate equates to about 28 times our 2027 non-GAAP earnings estimate, which excludes the amortization of acquired intangibles. For context, this is below the firm’s five-year average of 37 times. We use an 8.3% cost of equity and a 7.9% cost of capital (up from 7.2% assumption in our valuation model.
During our 2026-30 forecast period, we expect revenue to grow at about a 9% compound annual rate, with higher growth in indexes relative to analytics. We still expect analytics revenue to grow, albeit more slowly than the firm overall, with more competition in the analytics business generally, pressuring segment pricing power.
With the firm’s index segment representing over 70% of the firm’s operating profit, the index segment is by far the most important segment to our fair value estimate. The index subscription business has been relatively steady, and we forecast about 9%-11% revenue growth over the next five years. While this is slightly higher than recent levels, we believe cancellations were elevated, and client conditions from 2022-24 were uniquely tough from an asset-level perspective. We expect some of the improvement from markets in 2025 to flow through in 2026.
Our growth forecast is based on pricing of 3%-4% per year, with the remaining growth driven by net new sales, and faster growth among nonasset manager segments, such as wealth managers and hedge funds. Asset-based fee revenue in indexes depends on market performance and ETF flows, which can be volatile and unpredictable. In our base case, we forecast assets in ETFs linked to MSCI indexes to grow at about 13% per year after 2026, driven by net inflows and market appreciation. We model license fee rates on asset-based fees to drop by about 4% per year during our forecast period, reflecting contract negotiations and mix shifts toward lower-fee products.
The firm’s analytics business is more competitive than its index segment, and we model growth to average about 6% over the next five years. We expect lower pricing in the Analytics business than in the index business.
For sustainability and climate, we expect more choppy trends. Sustainability and climate have seen a tough environment in the US, which we expect to continue. Management views this slowdown as cyclical rather than structural and believes that, in the future, environmental concerns and social issues (such as immigration) will become more important to the risk and return of financial assets. Overall, we are unconvinced of a rebound in this segment and model low-single-digit revenue growth during our forecast period.
Within private assets, we expect high-single-digit growth with stronger growth in private capital solutions as the segment benefits from the rise of private asset investing. That said, retention trends can be choppy in this segment.
Given high incremental margins in index, we still expect margin expansion but at a slower pace. From 2025's 60.8%, we model for adjusted EBITDA margins of 61.4% and 61.8% in 2026 and 2027 respectively, which is down from 62.0% and 62.7%.
Economic moat
We believe MSCI warrants a wide Morningstar Economic Moat Rating based on the intangible assets of its index franchise. MSCI has built a strong moat and brand with its flagship index benchmarks, notably the MSCI EAFE Index, MSCI ACWI Index, and MSCI Emerging Markets Index. MSCI monetizes its indexes in primarily three ways: subscriptions, asset-linked fees, and transaction royalties on exchange-traded futures and options.
Active asset managers pay to benchmark performance against an index. Index benchmarks are critical to asset owners, asset managers, and consultants, who often have little incentive to switch benchmarks. Once an index becomes dominant in a segment, it tends to stay that way. An asset manager may prefer to be indexed against an S&P emerging-markets index, for example, but if asset owners and consultants prefer the MSCI Emerging Markets Index, the asset manager would risk outflows. Additionally, the data subscription for active asset managers represents a small percentage of the firm’s overall cost. MSCI’s growth in the index subscription business has been at a healthy high-single-digit growth rate with management suggesting that 3%-4% of this growth is driven by price increases.
Another way MSCI monetizes its indexes' intellectual property is through passive exchange-traded and mutual funds that track them. Net inflows and market appreciation have driven strong growth in the firm’s asset-based fees. MSCI’s ETF business is largely tied to BlackRock’s iShares franchise. In 2019, BlackRock and MSCI signed a 10-year agreement with respect to licensing and announced an extension to 2035 on its fourth quarter 2025 earnings call. While the deal does include modest price reductions when certain asset tiers are hit, overall, the initial impact was less than feared.
MSCI’s fees have some relationship to an ETF’s fee ratio. As an example, we believe the license fees earned on the iShares Core MSCI EAFE ETF (expense ratio 0.07%) are meaningfully lower than the iShares MSCI EAFE ETF (expense ratio 0.32%). Even as fee rates decline, we still expect MSCI to garner a significant share of the value chain from its index franchise. By our calculations, MSCI's average fee rate on ETFs declined 2% from 2023 to 2025, which we believe is a slower decline that ETF fees.
MSCI also monetizes its index IP through the trading of options and futures of MSCI indexes. Given the outsize importance of the S&P 500 index in global equity markets (as well as the VIX), MSCI’s trading royalty revenue is significantly smaller than S&P’s, but off a smaller base, MSCI’s growth has been strong. Generally, index providers choose one exchange to be the exclusive venue of their licensed products. Because traders will go to where the index is traded, we believe the index providers have greater leverage than the exchanges. In 2007, Russell switched from CME Group to Intercontinental Exchange and then back to CME in 2017 for its index derivatives. In Asia, MSCI recently switched some of its business from the Singapore to the Hong Kong exchange. It noted on a 2020 earnings call, "We are benefiting slightly from improved economics from our exchange partners, most notably in Asia versus the prior quarter," which supports our view of the index provider’s strong negotiating position.
We view the MSCI analytics segment, which consists largely of its Barra and RiskMetrics acquisitions, as a narrow-moat business based on switching costs. The segment provides risk management, performance attribution, and portfolio management applications to asset owners and asset managers. Because MSCI analytics applications are embedded in clients’ workflows, there are switching costs, and we believe firms don’t take the decision to switch providers lightly. That said, there are competitors, such as FactSet, BlackRock’s Aladdin, Axioma (Deutsche Boerse), and Bloomberg, and we believe users can be price-sensitive for these products. Unlike in index subscriptions, where a switch to a competitor is rare (losses tend to be from a firm shutting down), analytics subscription cancellations are mixed between competitive defections and firms shutting down.
At over 10% of firmwide revenue, MSCI’s sustainability and climate data segment has been an important focus area for the firm. As an early mover and now market leader, MSCI’s ESG business boasts coverage of 14,800-plus issuers, has more than 700 climate change metrics, and covers 10,000-plus issuers. We believe that would be difficult for a competitor to match, and even so, MSCI’s long record (which could be useful in seeing how past ESG metrics have translated into performance) provides another barrier to entry. ESG-based investing has, however, faced some political backlash and underperformance issues and growth has slowed considerably. MSCI's private assets segment consists of Real Capital Analytics and Private Capital Solutions (Burgiss). Real Capital Analytics provides commercial real estate transaction and capital flows data. Burgiss provides benchmarking and performance analytics for private assets, sourcing data directly from limited partners. As this data is not public, we believe this type of unique aggregated data can form a moat. That said, with less than 10% of the firm's revenue from its private assets segment, we do not view these businesses as material enough to inform our overall moat rating.
Bull case
MSCI has been a big beneficiary of the shift to passive investments, and it will particularly benefit if non-US equity markets, which have underperformed the US market, rebound sharply.
Institutional investors prefer to work with asset managers that license benchmarks aligned with their mandates; this is a substantial advantage for MSCI and should lend itself to strong pricing power, particularly as non-US equity markets have fared well recently.
With Real Capital Analytics and Burgiss, MSCI may benefit more than the market expects from the growth in private asset investing.
Bear case
With the rise of passive investing, MSCI's index revenue is now more closely linked to asset-based fees, which are more cyclical in nature.
MSCI faces key customer risk, with about 10% of its revenue derived from BlackRock, which could exercise its more meaningful negotiating power to seek lower fees for index licensing. In addition, BlackRock’s technology unit (Aladdin) competes with MSCI Analytics.
Outflows, fee compression, and weak markets could make it hard for MSCI to generate new sales to active asset managers, its largest subscription client segment.
By Rajiv Bhatia, CFA
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:21 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
MSCI Inc discussion 0 comments