Royal Caribbean
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Travel Services
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Royal Caribbean (RCL) | 79.30B | 17.54 | 6.77 | 1.86% |
| Booking Holdings (BKNG) | 107.77B | 15.73 | -10.36 | 1.13% |
| Airbnb (ABNB) | 100.09B | 31.96 | 10.75 | 0.00% |
| Carnival (CCL) | 35.75B | 11.71 | 2.52 | 1.69% |
| Viking Holdings (VIK) | 29.58B | 31.66 | 16.55 | 0.00% |
| Expedia (EXPE) | 27.86B | 13.77 | 16.86 | 0.78% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 8.9% above Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Royal delivered a 0.9% lift in third-quarter net revenue yield and a 1.9% decline in net cruise costs, excluding fuel. This led to adjusted EPS of $6.57, about $0.25 above the firm’s outlook. The firm raised its 2026 EPS outlook to $17.85-$17.95 from $17.73-$17.87, driving shares 6% higher.
Why it matters: While some of the recent profit upside came from strong close-in demand, a shift in costs also helped. With the new outlook, we plan to lower fourth-quarter EPS by about $0.10, with yields 100 basis points lower and costs 100 basis points higher than before. Still, the overarching demand picture is positive. 2027 bookings are ahead of historical levels at higher rates. Next year's bookings have increased at a midteen clip since July, resulting in $6 billion in customer deposits, indicating vacations continue to take priority with consumers. Recall, in 2027, Royal stands to benefit from the launch of river cruising, the addition of the Sandals joint venture (set to close in early 2027), and the deployment of Hero of the Seas. New hardware and expansion at land destinations should support longer-term sales and profit growth.
The bottom line: We plan to raise our $262 fair value estimate for narrow-moat Royal Caribbean by a mid-single-digit rate for an improved 2026 outlook, faster capacity growth, and time value. We view shares as slightly overvalued, even as investors largely pull back on discretionary exposure. Royal hasn’t strayed from its focus on moderate capacity and yield growth backed by rigorous cost discipline. With only low single-digit price and cost growth, we think Royal should continue to print roughly 40% adjusted EBITDA margins, well above the low 30% rate pre-covid. This should allow Royal to meet its Perfecta goals of delivering 20% adjusted EPS growth from 2024 to 2027 and high-teen ROICs. Our forecast before the earnings call included roughly 20% EPS growth and a 16% ROIC in 2027, before including the Sandals investment.
Fair value
We are raising our fair value estimate to $270 per share from $262 to reflect an improved 2026 outlook, faster capacity growth, and time value. A third-quarter net yield lift of 0.9% and net cruise cost decline excluding fuel of 1.9% supported adjusted earnings per share of $6.57, ahead of its $6.26-$6.36 guidance, benefiting from solid close-in demand and controlled costs. Despite ongoing discord with Iran, which has elevated fuel costs and led to some consumer hesitancy around Mediterranean bookings, Royal raised its full-year EPS outlook to $17.85-$17.95 from $17.73-$17.87. Our updated forecast calls for 2026 net revenue yield growth of 2.7% (near our 2.65% prior forecast) and net cruise costs excluding fuel of 0.3% (down 10 basis points from prior), leading to adjusted EPS of $17.94.
Our long-term estimates are unchanged, supported by new hardware, riveting onboard and excursion opportunities, and the expansion into nascent markets (Asia, luxury, river), driving modest price increases over time. However, tailwinds could be derailed by higher potential fuel prices and foreign exchange. We expect that pricing can grow 3% annually longer term, with capacity growth of 3% in the final five years of our outlook as Royal Caribbean optimizes its deployment strategy. In the longer term, we have both pricing and costs stabilizing at a low-single-digit growth rate. We anticipate Royal Caribbean's EBITDA margins can remain at a high-30% rate over our forecast if the firm continues to control costs.
Royal Caribbean generated average returns on invested capital of more than 9% over the three years ended 2019; however, we believe it will handily surpass this level over the next five years, generating ROICs of 17%, in line with its Perfecta program goal.
Economic moat
We assign Royal Caribbean a Narrow Morningstar Economic Moat Rating based on brand intangible assets and efficient scale. Before January 2024, we had a no-moat rating for Royal due to the uncertainty around the length of lockdowns and the impact on ROICs. We forecast ROICs that are even better than the pre-covid-19 period over our outlook, reaching 23% at the end of our forecast versus 8% in 2019 (when the firm previously held a Narrow Moat Rating), well above our 10% weighted average cost of capital estimate.
We think Royal has a brand intangible asset edge, evidenced by pricing power, industry concentration, and risk aversion that dictates purchasing decisions. Pricing power has been displayed more reliably among the cruise majors in the last decade.
We attribute pricing growth to better revenue management systems, more dynamic pricing, and a stepped-up marketing strategy. But we also think Royal’s brands offer unique opportunities through products like Perfect Day at Coco Cay. While Coco Cay, the private island owned by Royal Caribbean, was a first mover in destination experiences, Carnival and Norwegian have followed suit with similar offerings. But there is enough interest in cruising for all companies to benefit, given the limited capacity of cruise ships relative to the demand of the greater vacation market. We expect Royal will continue to pursue destination development (including destinations in Mexico, Vanuatu, Santorini, and beyond) to capitalize on additional itinerary excursion revenue.
Having such destinations on itineraries also protects pricing at Royal, as it allows the firm to pursue a strategic marketing plan, avoiding discounting. This strategy highlights the firm’s differentiated offerings rather than lowering prices to optimize occupancy, conveying to consumers that early booking is the best strategy to optimize price and room choice. Moreover, to prevent discounting during times of waning demand, the company utilizes bundling tactics to entice consumers, holding its pricing firm.
Considering the mix of repeat travelers in cruising and the aversion of travelers to trying a different brand with a dissimilar experience, we believe loyalty exists for passengers. For comparison, hotel operator chains get around 50%-65% of room nights booked by loyalty members on average, and we believe this level is more than 40% at Royal, which has led to supported market share. Plus, the increasing benefits that loyalty members obtain as they travel with their preferred brands aids in driving repeat business. For Royal Caribbean, after sailing just three nights with the brand, Crown & Anchor Society members get priority check-in, exclusive rates, and reduced-rate upgrades, among other amenities, rewarding those who stick with the brand. We think this has surfaced in resilient market share over time, given finite building capacity and the high fixed costs.
We expect Royal will continue to drive higher pricing through its capital spending programs set to elevate the brands by uplifting the product while in dry dock, increasing consumer willingness to pay for sailing on that updated hardware, and bolstering spend around new onboard activities. Royal is investing in fleet modernization to improve consistency in the experience across the line, with plans to revamp Harmony, Ovation, and Liberty at the Royal brand in 2026. Generally, refurbished ships that have been put back into existing markets have performed well, garnering improved yields (pricing, often a mid-single-digit or more above existing hardware) versus pre-dry dock performance. We think Royal should be able to increase pricing by around 3% annually over the long term, near the roughly 2.4% inflation Morningstar expects between 2026-30.
We also see efficient scale as a key moat source, which has often been reflected in highly capital-intensive industries. This is ascribed to the cost of ships (which can run north of $1 billion for new construction), increasing the capital requirements of operators, and the high fixed costs associated with the cruise model (we believe more than two-thirds of costs are fixed in the short run).
We see meaningful barriers to entry, which bolster the efficient scale moat source. For example, new peers may be unable to access cheap financing through export credit facilities, making the cost of ship builds less affordable. Export credit agencies offer loans, guarantees, and insurance to help local shipbuilders limit the risk of selling goods and services abroad, resulting in lower interest costs. Royal pays 4% or less on most of its ship financing, below current market rates. Smaller operators don’t always have access to such debt—before Silversea paired up with Royal Caribbean, it pursued a private placement for its $550 million notes, which were priced at 7.25% to refinance existing debt and new ship builds. Furthermore, along with special financing around shipbuilding, there is limited global capacity for new hardware, making a fast ramp of a new peer difficult.
Additional evidence of efficient scale stems from sunk costs and historical precedent. As proof of the deep pockets essential to support passenger and capacity growth while remaining prominent in the industry, Royal had already devoted nearly $38 billion in net property, plant, and equipment as of Sept. 30. With respect to new entrants, Morningstar’s methodology indicates that if a market has seen little entry or exit over time, efficient scale is more likely to be present. Given that Royal’s share hasn’t shifted in recent years (at around 25% over the last decade), we believe the efficient scale moat source will remain in place over the next decade-plus, particularly given the fixed capacity of shipbuilders and the corresponding constraints.
Bull case
If consumer preference for experiences over things persists, yields could rise faster than we currently forecast as demand increases.
A reversion in fuel prices could help benefit the cost structure, as Royal Caribbean has partially floating energy prices (with only about 50% of fuel costs hedged historically).
As Royal reenters the China market, the nascent Asia-Pacific market provides upside. The four largest operators had capacity for nearly 4 million passengers prior to the pandemic, which offers opportunity for Royal to optimize deployment globally.
Bear case
Weakness in consumer spending stemming from an economic downturn could affect discretionary spending and cause pricing to soften intermittently.
Volatility in input prices, including commodity prices, energy, labor, and food, could cause profits to contract. Inflation across categories has become a more challenging headwind in recent years.
Health-related concerns could return, or new and unexpected regulations could pressure profits, leading to liquidity concerns if secular shifts in demand arise. Geopolitical risks could also limit certain geographic opportunities.
By Jaime M. Katz, CFA
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:14 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Royal Caribbean discussion 0 comments