Vodafone
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Telecom Services
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vodafone (VOD) | 32.48B | -4.96 | 0.69 | 3.73% |
| Verizon (VZ) | 192.64B | 11.86 | 1.82 | 6.05% |
| T-Mobile US (TMUS) | 175.42B | 15.97 | 3.12 | 2.46% |
| AT&T (T) | 150.29B | 11.99 | 1.41 | 4.98% |
| Comcast (CMCSA) | 88.42B | 7.88 | 0.96 | 5.30% |
| America Movil SAB de CV (AMX) | 74.06B | 15.57 | 3.02 | 2.37% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 21.3% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Vodafone raised fiscal 2027 guidance, lifting adjusted EBITDAaL to EUR 13.2 billion-EUR 13.4 billion from EUR 13.0 billion-EUR 13.3 billion and adjusted free cash flow to EUR 2.8 billion-EUR 3.0 billion from EUR 2.6 billion-EUR 2.9 billion. First-half adjusted EBITDAaL rose 6.4% organically.
Why it matters: Cost-cutting continues to show up. Vodafone booked over EUR 200 million in gross savings in the first half, including EUR 50 million in UK synergies, and lifted its annual UK synergy target to GBP 800 million by fiscal 2030 from GBP 700 million previously. The guidance midpoint implies free cash flow growth above 20%.
Germany remains the key thing to watch. Organic service revenue fell 0.5% in the second quarter as mobile service revenue dropped 1.9%, and German adjusted EBITDA after leases fell 3.2% organically in the first half. Deutsche Telekom and its low-end Congstar brand keep taking share, adding a staggering net 322,000 postpaid customers this same quarter. Vodafone’s mobile postpaid customers stabilized with about 10,000 net additions this quarter, but it lost 100,000 broadband subscribers.
The bottom line: We maintain our GBX 130 fair value estimate for no-moat Vodafone. Shares, trading at about GBX 117, look slightly undervalued. Our fair value estimate implies a 4.1 times forward enterprise value/EBITDAaL, which is below the European peer median of 5.8 times. Should Vodafone prove it can continue to deliver on its multiyear double-digit organic free cash flow growth target, we estimate the firm could narrow the valuation gap versus peers and increase investor confidence. This could create additional upside, lifting our fair value estimate even further. Our model assumes modest EBITDAaL margin expansion for now, at 29.4% in our terminal year versus 28.1% in fiscal 2026 and 29.5% in the first half of 2027. In our view, Vega owner Xavier Niel's completion of an acquisition of a 16% stake in Vodafone by year-end could be a further turnaround catalyst.
Fair value
Our fair value estimate for Vodafone ADR shares is $17 per share.
We model flat sales for Vodafone over the next 10 years, due to the overall pricing pressure of the telecommunications sector, where high competition and a challenging regulatory environment weigh on firms. We model flat adjusted EBITDAaL margins long-term, as revenue pressures are offset by cost controls. In our view, the arrival of Xavier Niel (Iliad) as an anchor shareholder brings potential to unlock shareholder value through cost controls and make Vodafone more efficient. Niel and its team have deep operational knowledge in operating telecoms cost-efficiently, and we expect they will push for operational changes. We model a 29.5% adjusted EBITDAaL margin in our terminal year, flat versus our 29% expectation for 2027 but higher than our previous 27.5%.
From a geographical perspective, we expect flat to low-single-digit revenue declines in all of Vodafone's European markets, which should be offset by mid-single-digit growth in African countries. In Germany, Vodafone keeps losing fixed-line subscribers to Deutsche Telekom, which is hurting its top line. Recovering subscribers will be a delicate balancing act for Vodafone. If Vodafone is too aggressive with promotions and discounts to regain customers, it can undermine the very revenue trajectory it is trying to protect. A gradual approach is the only credible path, but it is a slow one.
We model flat capital spending in the medium term, remaining at around EUR 8 billion-EUR 8.5 billion annually, including spectrum. Vodafone has significant equity stakes in tower firms Vantage Towers, Inwit, and Cornerstone.
Economic moat
We assign Vodafone a no moat rating. Vodafone's returns on invested capital are below its cost of capital. Given the highly competitive nature of the industry, we have little certainty that the company will be able to consistently generate excess ROICs over the next 10 years.
Mobile and fixed-line telecom services are generally commodity products with little differentiation. European telecom markets are mature, no-growth markets, meaning the overall profit pool that companies fight for is stable or declining. Although fixed-line and wireless networks naturally present efficient scale characteristics, this moat source has eroded in Europe due to network duplication, irrational behavior, and a poor regulatory setup. European telecoms normally don’t generate excess returns on invested capital, and when they do, the durability of these returns is uncertain due to low differentiation, aggressive competition from low-cost providers, and regulation.
In mobile networks, the collaboration between European operators has historically been low. Instead of reaping the economies of scale of deploying a unique tower where several mobile network operators can place radio equipment, most European operators opted for their own infrastructure, resulting in higher duplication and capital expenditures. Cross-country efficiencies are very low due to separate spectrum auctions by country, national government influence, and cultural differences.
In broadband networks, the efficient scale moat source is more prevalent, but in many cases is still not enough to generate consistent excess returns on invested capital. Deploying underground channels for fixed-line cables is costly and complicated, as new lines may affect entire neighborhoods, traffic flows, or coincide with other underground infrastructure like water pipes. Still, many countries have built several broadband networks on top of each other—normally, a nationwide copper/fiber network, a cable network, and additional regional networks. In the UK, for instance, network duplication has reached a high level, with some urban areas covered by three or even four different broadband networks.
The European regulatory environment is complex, with too many layers, and it is not supportive of moat creation. The European Commission is a major drag on consolidation and cost synergies, having blocked most merger and acquisition deals or imposed harsh remedies on firms. Even when a player is allowed to consolidate, the commission might force it to sell assets to a new entrant, wrecking the purpose of the merger. National regulators might have different views on key matters, and are often more concerned about consumers than shareholders, and periodically review their markets to look for signs of excessive concentration. Some of these reviews have led to governments forcing the entrance of new players on advantageous terms, such as Iliad in France in 2011, MasMovil in Spain in 2019, and Digi in Belgium in 2024. Once telecom prices rebase to a lower level, they rarely recover.
Vodafone’s largest market is Germany, where it is the second-largest player in both the mobile and fixed-line segments after Deutsche Telekom. The German mobile market has been a stable one for more than a decade. In 2019, 1&1 Drillisch acquired spectrum in the 3.5-gigahertz band and aims to transition from a mobile virtual network operator to a mobile network operator, but so far, 1&1 has shown rational behavior, which is important to maintain acceptable returns on invested capital. Still, 1&1’s network rollout will increase costs for the company, so we expect it will try to win some market share, something that could bring some price pressure to the German mobile market. Vodafone owns an extensive cable network due to the acquisitions of Kabel Deutschland in 2013 and Liberty Global Germany in 2019. The acquisitions were highly complementary as Kabel and Liberty covered different areas of the country. Still, we see Vodafone's cable network as inferior to that of Deutsche Telekom, which has executed an exceptional broadband strategy during the last decade. The German regulatory environment is generally good, as government and competition authorities have allowed operators to improve networks at their own pace.
In the UK, Vodafone completed a merger with CK Hutchison in 2025, effectively consolidating the market from four to three operators. We look favorably upon this move and believe the merger will create value as both firms can realize cost synergies while prices remain stable or grow slightly. Unlike BT Group and Virgin Media O2, Vodafone lacks its own fixed network; it relies on renting network capacity from other network providers to resell broadband services, a low-margin activity.
Across the rest of Europe (Portugal, Greece, Ireland, Czech Republic, Hungary, and Romania), Vodafone enjoys good competitive positions. In most of these countries, Vodafone enjoys a number-one or number-two position by share in the mobile market and additionally owns some cable networks after the acquisition of Liberty Global’s assets (Czech Republic, Hungary, Romania) in 2019, with good broadband penetration rates (above 40%).
Vodafone derives more than 20% of revenue from its operations in South Africa, Egypt, Turkey, and other African and Middle Eastern countries, where it is a mobile operator (very little fixed-line revenue with no proprietary fixed-line networks). The main advantage of some emerging markets tends to be limited competition, with sometimes only two or three mobile network operators per country. However, Vodafone’s emerging markets are more saturated, sometimes having four or five operators. The main advantage of these markets is that users are normally charged for incremental usage, with large data plans being less common. Vodafone owns 50% of Vantage Towers, its tower division, through a joint venture. Wireless tower businesses generally have more attractive unit economics than telecom businesses.
Bull case
An ambitious cost plan is, in our view, the key catalyst for shares to rerate higher, but so far, progress on the cost front is rather disappointing.
A credible two-year to three-year strategic plan that would target consistent mid-single-digit organic growth in EBITDAaL through cost discipline and low-single-digit revenue growth would rerate the stock.
Exposure to growing markets in Africa and the Middle East should help top-line growth.
Bear case
Regulation remains very tough for European telecoms, preventing effective consolidation and constantly encouraging the entrance of new players that drop prices.
Vodafone keeps losing market share to Deutsche Telekom in Germany due to a weaker network position and poorer execution.
Vodafone can do much more in terms of cost savings. Despite management's claims of cost reductions, the total number of employees has not declined, and selling and administrative expenses have grown.
By Javier Correonero
Quote time 2026-11-20 19:30:06 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Vodafone discussion 0 comments