First Solar
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Solar
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| First Solar (FSLR) | 14.79B | 7.96 | 1.36 | 0.00% |
| Nextpower (NXT) | 10.11B | 16.91 | 3.82 | 0.00% |
| Enphase Energy (ENPH) | 2.60B | 29.30 | 2.09 | 0.00% |
| Sunrun (RUN) | 1.60B | 3.33 | 0.43 | 0.00% |
| SolarEdge Technologies (SEDG) | 1.13B | -4.81 | 2.67 | 0.00% |
| Shoals Technologies (SHLS) | 1.09B | 29.45 | 1.71 | 0.00% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 38.8% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
First Solar's net sales fell to $1.23 billion, down 23% from the same period last year. Adjusted EBITDA was up 11% to $744 million, net income grew 11%, and gross margins expanded by 20 percentage points.
Why it matters: First Solar benefits from direct manufacturing tax credits and a protectionist US market. This will continue to reduce First Solar's cost of goods sold and support historically high margins. First Solar expects to sell 16-17 gigawatts, down from its prior 17 GW-18.2 GW estimate. Net sales expectations for the year were lowered by $300 million to a range of $4.6 billion-$4.9 billion. Lower volumes in India was the main driver. US sales are estimated at 12.2-13.1 GW. The company's US backlog declined to 44 GW, with 6 GW of bookings more than offset by the 11.7 GW sold year to date. We continue to appreciate management's focus on optimizing average sales price. The switch from multi-year framework agreements to project-specific agreements aided this initiative.
The bottom line: We maintain our $191 per share fair value estimate for no-moat First Solar. We expect to reduce near-term volumes. The lower-margin India sales affect our fair value estimate by less than $1 per share. We don't expect to materially alter our near- and long-term sales expectations, which incorporate declines as manufacturing tax credits begin to roll off after 2030. Management continues good discipline with its contracting strategy, with 1.4 GW of US gross bookings at an average selling price of $0.36 per watt during the quarter, in line with the previous quarter. South Carolina's finishing facility started phase 1 production recently. After phase 2, South Carolina's total output will range from 2.2 GW-2.5 GW.
Fair value
Our First Solar fair value is $191 after incorporating year-to-date financial and operational updates.
We adjusted near-term volumes for guidance though we raised our assumed average selling price over the medium term as an offset given the visibility management cited from its US bookings.
The key drivers behind our valuation include shipment volume, average selling prices, gross margin, capital expenditures, and US manufacturing incentives. We expect capacity to grow to 22 gigawatts by year-end 2027, thanks to US and India expansions, partially offset by lower Southeast Asia capacity.
We forecast average selling prices to rise modestly over the medium term to the low- to mid-$0.30 per watt range, before declining into the early 2030s as incentives expire. We forecast long-term gross margins (excluding tax credits) in the high single digit range. In addition, we incorporate US manufacturing tax credits of $0.17 per watt for US production.
Economic moat
We do not believe First Solar possesses an economic moat as we think the solar module industry is fiercely competitive, competes primarily on cost, and has a long history of poor returns on invested capital. However, we view the US policy in recent years as providing First Solar a much improved competitive position in its core market, the US.
While solar has experienced tremendous growth in installations over the past decade, solar module firms have not benefited. Cost declines have led to solar becoming economically attractive in more geographies and against traditional forms of generation. The primary driver behind these cost declines has been falling prices of solar modules (typically the largest single cost of a solar project).
Solar module production is heavily concentrated in Asia, with China representing the largest single country. We view this as driven by the region’s low-cost manufacturing base and the strategic importance the Chinese government placed on solar manufacturing.
As the industry scaled, products became increasingly commoditized, with limited long-lived differentiation (new innovations were quickly copied). We view the limited differentiation as also limiting customer switching costs in switching from one supplier to another. In particular, the utility-scale segment (First Solar’s targeted end market) sees a high degree of commoditization among products. Unlike a rooftop solar installation, where space constraints encourage the use of high-efficiency panels, utility-scale projects are more focused on lowest-cost rather than the most technologically advanced panels.
First Solar is unique in the broader solar module industry. Its technology—thin film (specifically cadmium telluride)—represents only a minor portion of the overall market. Crystalline silicon is the dominant technology across the industry, accounting for 95% of the market. C-Si benefits from its robust scale, long history, and higher efficiencies. In contrast, First Solar’s thin-film technology has lower efficiencies but benefits from a simple manufacturing process and higher energy yield in hot/humid climates.
While First Solar’s technology is unique in the industry, we view it as supporting a moat only to the extent that it enables a durable cost advantage over c-Si competitors. We do not view this to be the case and believe First Solar’s costs per watt to be modestly higher than that of its c-Si competitors. Raw material prices for c-Si (polysilicon) would have to increase materially on a continued basis to support a relative cost advantage for First Solar, which we view as unlikely.
Bull case
First Solar’s balance sheet strength has enabled the company to persist through solar cycles when competitors have failed.
First Solar’s thin-film cadmium telluride technology is unique in the industry and benefits from its simple manufacturing process and supply chain.
First Solar is well positioned to benefit from US solar manufacturing incentives.
Bear case
First Solar competes in the fiercely competitive and highly commoditized solar module industry.
First Solar’s cost per watt is generally higher than crystalline silicon peers.
First Solar's long-term competitiveness and financial performance hinge heavily on US policy decisions.
By Andrew Bischof, CFA, CPA
Quote time 2026-11-20 19:52:33 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
First Solar discussion 0 comments