Sunrun
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Solar
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sunrun (RUN) | 1.60B | 3.33 | 0.43 | 0.00% |
| First Solar (FSLR) | 14.79B | 7.96 | 1.36 | 0.00% |
| Nextpower (NXT) | 10.11B | 16.91 | 3.82 | 0.00% |
| Enphase Energy (ENPH) | 2.60B | 29.30 | 2.09 | 0.00% |
| SolarEdge Technologies (SEDG) | 1.13B | -4.81 | 2.67 | 0.00% |
| Shoals Technologies (SHLS) | 1.09B | 29.45 | 1.71 | 0.00% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 112.1% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Sunrun reported less than 18,000 subscriber additions during the first quarter, down over 25% year on year, while non-GAAP cash generation flipped to negative $59 million from positive $56 million last year. Results brought the stock price down nearly 5%, though it recovered some losses after hours.
Why it matters: Cash generation matters as we think investors are looking for potential cash returns. Still, we're not expecting cash returns in 2026, as we continue to believe debt reduction will remain management's focus, with safe-harboring investments to preserve tax credits through 2030. Management attributed the negative cash generation during the quarter to shifting certain project transaction activity from the first quarter to the second quarter. We think this is a sore point in the results, but Sunrun maintained full-year guidance. Subscriber additions declined as management traded volume for value by cutting ties with lower-margin affiliates, falling below our expectations. Still, we flag that the subscriber value of $1.1 billion was well above guidance, reflecting that battery sales are becoming more valuable.
The bottom line: We maintain our $14 fair value estimate for no-moat-rated Sunrun, coupled with our Very High Uncertainty Rating given uncertain public policy toward solar, as well as hard-to-call impacts from monetary policy. We'd already adopted a more cautious approach to cash generation. The market probably underappreciates Sunrun's ability to hit a 73% storage attachment rate, a key driver of the bull case. There are puts and takes here as Sunrun incurs concentration risk in certain markets, but on balance, it should help the firm's cash-generation efforts. We continue to aim to drop coverage of Sunrun on or about May 11.
Fair value
We are maintaining our $14 fair value estimate following fourth-quarter earnings.
Our fair value estimate is a summation of the company’s net earning assets, a 10-year forecast window, and a terminal value. We value the company's net earning assets based on a 7.5% discount rate and assumes a 20% renewal rate, a key factor in our valuation. Our renewal rate estimate is based on expected continued cost and technological advancements in solar energy, making it less likely customers will renew after their initial 20- to 25-year lease expires.
Our 10-year forecast combines our estimates for Sunrun’s subscriber additions and net subscriber value to arrive at annual value generated. We assume the US residential industry contracts in 2026 based off changes to residential solar tax credits, but grows in the range of 10% annually thereafter. Sunrun's business mix is expected to remain the majority lease over our forecast period.
Our terminal value assumes Sunrun’s business mix shifts to 100% cash sales. We assume an 8% EBITDA margin and a 3% terminal growth rate.
Economic moat
We assign a no-moat rating to Sunrun. While we think the company has scale advantages in solar lease financing, we do not believe its direct-to-consumer business has a competitive advantage.
Sunrun’s core product offering is its 20- to 25-year solar lease or power purchase agreement. The company goes to market with a hybrid approach, leveraging direct-to-consumer operations and a third-party dealer network. We estimate the majority of Sunrun’s business is from its direct operations following the 2020 acquisition of Vivint Solar.
The residential solar installation business is highly fragmented, consisting of thousands of installers across the US. We think there are good reasons for this, as the sale of residential solar is highly dependent on local factors such as utility rates, policies, and permitting. This has made it difficult for a national installation company to emerge, similar to industries such as home HVAC contractors. The top 10 residential solar installers have historically accounted for less than 50% market share.
Although Sunrun was the largest installer with midteens market share, we do not believe this demonstrates a moat. We view the fragmented industry landscape as evidence of the difficulty in establishing a national installation business such as Sunrun’s direct business. We view cost advantage as a potential moat source for direct installers that can offer the lowest installation costs, but we do not believe Sunrun has a material cost advantage over competitors. Further, we do not believe Sunrun has achieved sufficient brand recognition to warrant a moat.
Within its third-party dealer network, Sunrun primarily offers its platform of financing solutions, such as residential leases and PPAs.
We view Sunrun’s leadership in leases and PPAs as its strongest competitive advantage. Financing of leases and PPAs offers scale advantages to raise debt, such as asset-backed securities and tax equity, through monetization of federal tax credits. Sunrun's market share in the lease and PPA market was historically in the range of 33%-50%. However, because the direct-to-consumer business does not possess a moat, we view an overall no-moat rating as prudent.
Bull case
Sunrun is the leader in residential solar installations with high-teens market share.
Adjacent areas such as home batteries and grid services represent additional revenue opportunities.
Residential solar is still significantly underpenetrated at less than 5% of the addressable market.
Bear case
Sunrun’s economics are sensitive to customer renewal expectations, which are highly uncertain.
State policy reforms to net metering represent risks to rooftop solar demand.
Sunrun's business is highly sensitive to interest rate changes.
By Joshua Aguilar
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:28 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Sunrun discussion 0 comments