Sherwin-Williams
✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed
- Implied fair-value range of 305.31-383.71, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
- Current price is -1.4% below the average-multiple fair value of 344.51.
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Specialty Chemicals
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sherwin-Williams (SHW) | 82.08B | 31.25 | 20.64 | 0.94% |
| Linde (LIN) | 230.84B | 33.39 | 5.86 | 1.25% |
| Ecolab (ECL) | 82.65B | 40.10 | 7.93 | 0.99% |
| Air Products & Chemicals (APD) | 66.16B | 124.31 | 4.63 | 2.43% |
| PPG Industries (PPG) | 25.87B | 16.71 | 3.05 | 2.45% |
| International Flavors & Fragrances (IFF) | 19.94B | 112.14 | 1.50 | 2.01% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 0.1% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Sherwin-Williams shares fell 3% after the company reported third-quarter adjusted earnings per share of $3.63, below the FactSet consensus of $3.69, despite a 7.9% year-over-year increase in revenue to $6.86 billion, ahead of expectations of $6.78 billion.
Why it matters: Sherwin-Williams delivered solid top-line growth, with revenue rising from higher selling prices and acquisitions. However, gross margin contracted 140 basis points to 47.8%, as pricing gains were insufficient to fully offset an unfavorable product mix. Mid-single-digit price increases across key segments helped largely offset cost inflation, but faster growth in lower-margin products and dilution from the Suvinil acquisition weighed on consolidated gross margin. We view these mix-related pressures as largely temporary and expect profitability to improve as Suvinil becomes more fully integrated. Management also narrowed its full-year adjusted EPS guidance to $11.85-$12.15, maintaining the prior midpoint of $12.00. The revised outlook remains in line with our expectations and does not materially change our near-term earnings assumptions.
The bottom line: We are maintaining our $340 per share fair value estimate for wide moat Sherwin-Williams. We believe the company is well positioned to navigate near-term demand weakness and cost pressures, supported by its dense store network and strong relationships with pro painters, which have historically helped it outperform through industry cycles. We expect demand to remain subdued and uneven across most end markets through at least mid-2027. Against this backdrop, we forecast 6% revenue growth in 2027, driven primarily by pricing initiatives and market share gains, with limited volume growth. We expect this top-line growth to support about 70 basis points of annual expansion in adjusted operating margin in 2027, as continued price realization and internal cost efficiencies more than offset underlying cost inflation.
Fair value
We are maintaining our fair value estimate for Sherwin-Williams at $340 per share. Over our 10-year forecast horizon, we continue to expect solid growth and profitability, with consolidated revenue forecast to grow at a 5.3% compound annual rate and operating margins expanding by about 230 basis points. Our revised valuation equates to 29 times our 2026 adjusted earnings per share and a forward EV/EBITDA multiple of approximately 18.5 times.
We forecast the paint stores group to grow at a 5.4% compound annual rate over the next 10 years, with income before tax margins reaching 24.6% by 2035. While end markets remain uneven in the near term, we expect Sherwin to continue gaining share through disciplined pricing initiatives and continued investment in its store network and service capabilities.
Over the medium term, we expect the segment to benefit from improving residential repaint activity and a gradual recovery in housing construction. Residential repaint accounts for roughly one-third of segment revenue and typically follows a five to seven year repaint cycle. This cycle was pulled forward in 2021 amid elevated housing turnover and pandemic driven renovation activity. A portion of repaint demand is needs-based maintenance rather than discretionary remodeling, which provides a relatively stable source of demand even during softer housing environments. At the same time, activity tied to housing turnover and discretionary upgrades tends to be more cyclical, and we expect this portion of demand to provide an additional tailwind as existing home sales and consumer sentiment improve. A pickup in housing construction activity should provide an incremental tailwind. Higher mortgage rates have weighed on new construction in recent years, but we expect single-family housing starts to gradually return to growth beginning 2027, which should support paint demand tied to new residential builds.
We forecast the consumer brands segment to grow 6.7% compounded annual growth over the next decade, with margins reaching 17.2% by 2035. Do-it-yourself demand surged in 2020 as many people were stuck at home during pandemic lockdowns and were reluctant to have professional painters in their homes. Since then, demand has normalized and remains more closely tied to discretionary consumer spending, making the segment more sensitive to changes in consumer sentiment. However, Sherwin-Williams has maintained a leading position in the DIY paint market even during periods of weaker demand, which reinforces our confidence in the segment’s long-term growth.
We forecast the performance coatings segment to grow 4.1% compounded annual growth over the next decade, with margins reaching 15.2% by 2035. The combination of Sherwin’s legacy operations and the 2017 acquisition of Valspar established Sherwin as a significant player in global industrial coatings and we expect the segment's growth to largely track that of the industrial end markets it serves. Unlike some competitors, Sherwin has historically taken a disciplined approach to industrial coatings, focusing on end markets where it believes it can earn attractive returns rather than pursuing scale across all segments. Nevertheless, the industrial coatings market remains more competitive than the architectural paint market, and suppliers often compete on price during contract negotiations.
The second stage of our valuation model assumes Sherwin can generate an average return of 26% on new invested capital and 6.5% earnings-before-interest growth (implying a 25% reinvestment rate) for 10 years after our 10-year explicit forecast period.
Economic moat
We assign Sherwin-Williams a wide moat based on its intangible assets, and we believe the firm should be able to generate economic returns above the weighted average cost of capital for at least the next 20 years. We estimate the return on invested capital to average 19.8% over our 10-year forecast period, well above our weighted-average cost of capital of 7.5%.
The paint stores group is Sherwin’s largest segment and primarily serves professional painters, builders, property managers, and certain industrial customers. We believe this segment merits a wide moat, underpinned by the company’s dense store network and strong brand reputation among professional painters for consistent quality and reliability. Independent surveys reinforce this position. Sherwin-Williams ranked the highest in interior and exterior paint, as well as in the paint retailer category, in the 2025 J.D. Power survey. Zonda’s 2023 Builder Brand Use Study ranked Sherwin as the paint brand most familiar to builders and the one most frequently used over the past two years.
The company’s vertically integrated distribution model allows it to control customer relationships and deliver a level of service that is difficult for competitors who are relying on third-party retail channels to replicate. Its extensive network of over 4,800 stores ensures convenient access to products near job sites. Contractors often operate on tight schedules where downtime can be costly, and the proximity to Sherwin stores allows them to quickly replenish supplies without significant travel time. Beyond convenience, the stores function as service hubs that provide color matching, product recommendations, and technical support tailored to professional customers. Sherwin has also built a range of services that embed the company into a contractor’s day-to-day operations. Programs such as the PRO+ platform effectively act as a back office for small and midsize painting businesses, offering features such as volume-based rewards programs, digital ordering platforms, and detailed purchase records that allow stores to instantly retrieve exact paint formulas from prior jobs if a contractor needs to perform touch-ups years later. Sherwin also offers 0% interest credit lines that allow contractors to purchase materials upfront and repay the balance after receiving payment from their own customers, improving working capital management for small businesses. In addition, optional job-site delivery services for large projects reduce the need for contractors to send crew members to pick up supplies, saving time and labor.
Labor typically accounts for 80%-90% of the total cost of a painting project, while materials represent only 10%-20%. As a result, professional contractors prioritize products that improve job-site efficiency and reduce the risk of rework rather than focusing solely on the upfront price of paint. We believe this dynamic supports Sherwin’s ability to maintain premium pricing. The company has implemented annual price increases, typically in the mid- to high-single-digit range, which have offset input cost pressures over time, and importantly, volumes have remained resilient despite these increases.
The consumer brands group sells Sherwin-branded paints and coatings primarily through third-party retailers such as Lowe's and Menards, and we believe the segment also warrants a wide moat. Roughly 80%-85% of customers in this channel are do-it-yourself consumers, with professional painters accounting for the remainder. While DIY customers tend to be more price-sensitive and can easily compare products across brands, Sherwin benefits from strong brand recognition and a reputation for product quality that supports demand. The company holds the leading share of decorative paint sold through retail channels at roughly 34%, ahead of Masco at approximately 25%.
The performance coatings group primarily serves industrial customers across end markets such as packaging, automotive refinish, marine, and general manufacturing. The segment’s scale expanded significantly after the Valspar acquisition, which strengthened Sherwin’s position in industrial and packaging coatings globally. We believe the segment benefits from a narrow economic moat primarily driven by switching costs, as coatings are often integrated into customers’ manufacturing processes and tailored to specific production requirements. Industrial coatings are typically engineered to meet a customer’s exact specifications and performance characteristics, such as dry time, cure time, durability, and abrasion resistance, which can directly affect production efficiency and the quality of the finished product. In many cases, specialized application equipment and tightly controlled processes are designed around a particular coating system. This dynamic creates meaningful customer stickiness that is generally not present in the architectural paint market. In certain end markets, such as packaging, switching costs are further reinforced by regulatory and qualification barriers. Coating used in food and beverage cans, for example, must meet strict regulatory standards enforced by agencies such as the US Food and Drug Administration and other international safety authorities. Once a coating system is approved and integrated into a manufacturer’s production line, customers are often reluctant to undergo the time consuming and costly requalification process required to introduce a new supplier. These regulatory hurdles and technical integration requirements create durable relationships between coating suppliers and customers, supporting the segment’s narrow moat.
Bull case
Professional painters have favored Sherwin-Williams products for decades, fostering strong brand loyalty and giving the company meaningful pricing power.
Sherwin’s large network of company-owned stores allows it to control distribution, maintain product availability, and provide technical support to painters. This strengthens customer relationships and creates entry barriers for competitors.
As housing turnover and construction activity recover, demand across Sherwin’s key end markets should improve, creating favorable conditions for volume growth and continued market share gains.
Bear case
A sustained slowdown in housing turnover, housing starts, and commercial construction could limit volume growth in the near term.
Higher cost of raw materials such as titanium dioxide or petrochemicals could lead to margin contraction if Sherwin is not able to pass along those costs to customers.
Sherwin has continued to open 80-100 company-owned stores per year, but market saturation could become a concern over time. If the pace slows, the company’s ability to drive incremental growth through network expansion could moderate.
By Rashmi Nair
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:20 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Sherwin-Williams discussion 0 comments