Skip to content

Vale SA

US · VALE #352 by market cap Listed 1970
9.49 -0.34 -3.46%
Periodic snapshot; not a real-time feed. · 2026-11-20 20:02

Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range

P/B ratio 1.26 Cheap vs history 25th percentile
5-year average 1.61 · #23 of 56 in Other Industrial Metals & Mining
P/E ratio 70.13 Expensive vs history 99th percentile
5-year average 9.15 · forward 9.25 · #16 of 16 in Other Industrial Metals & Mining
P/S ratio 1.15 Cheap vs history 25th percentile
5-year average 1.38 · forward 1.20 · #5 of 25 in Other Industrial Metals & Mining

Vs. peers Other Industrial Metals & Mining

Company Market cap P/E (TTM) P/B Div yield
Vale SA (VALE) 40.39B 59.31 1.06 8.88%
BHP Group Ltd (BHP) 170.74B 17.39 3.45 3.96%
Rio Tinto (RIO) 118.30B 9.85 1.81 5.53%
MP Materials (MP) 6.05B -169.75 3.10 0.00%
Materion (MTRN) 3.81B 37.39 3.70 0.31%
Skeena Resources (SKE) 2.99B -15.82 30.71 0.00%

Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.

Morningstar

★★★★☆ Fair value15.00 Economic moatNone UncertaintyHigh

Trading 58.1% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.

Analyst note

Vale's third-quarter adjusted EBITDA fell 20% from the same quarter last year to USD 3.5 billion, and 14% from the prior quarter. Reduced iron ore earnings on lower realized prices and higher unit costs were partially offset by improved base metals earnings due to stronger prices.

Why it matters: The result is tracking below our full-year expectations, driven by lower iron ore price realizations and volumes. Management now guides iron ore production and capital expenditure to come in at the low end of their unchanged ranges, while copper and nickel are guided to the upper half of theirs. We reduce our assumed iron ore price realization to 90% from 92% and incorporate the minor guidance changes. Our near-term EPS estimates fall by an average of 5%, partially offset by lower forecast capital expenditure over this period, with our midcycle estimates little changed.

The bottom line: We retain our USD 15 fair value estimate for no-moat Vale. Shares are around 25% undervalued, partly due to the unexpected victory of incumbent Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva over more business-friendly Flávio Bolsonaro in the Brazil Presidential election runoff. This has led to large declines in the Brazilian share market and in the value of the Brazilian real versus the US dollar. Yet with opposition parties controlling the new Congress, major policy changes that pressure Vale into materially value-destructive actions are unlikely. While it has faced more government influence during Lula's current term, the impact has been modest, and we expect this to continue. With a strong balance sheet, we would welcome value-accretive buybacks at the current share price.

Big picture: While the market is likely also concerned with the headwinds affecting margins, we think many are temporary. These include higher diesel and freight costs due to disruptions from the Iran war, albeit reduced by near-term fuel hedges and long-term shipping contracts at fixed rates.

While we can't predict when the conflict will be resolved, we think it will be sooner or later, leading to moderating diesel and freight costs as markets normalize.

Vale's revenue is denominated in US dollars, but most of its operations, led by its key iron ore business, are in Brazil. We also don't try to predict foreign exchange rates, but with a significant portion of its costs such as labor denominated in Brazilian real, a weaker currency against the U.S. dollar is, on balance, a tailwind for earnings.

As it increases iron ore sales to our unchanged forecast of about 360 million metric tons in 2030, from 320 million in 2026, we expect the average iron content of its ore to rise as well. We forecast it at between 63% and 64% then, up from 62% to 63% now. This will likely improve price realizations relative to the 61% benchmark and help lower unit costs, along with higher volumes.

We retain our 2026 unit cast cost forecast of USD 23 per metric ton, at the midpoint of guidance between USD 22.50 and USD 23.50

The iron ore business comprised about 70% of the quarter's adjusted EBITDA. While production fell 6% to 88 million metric tons, sales were flat at 86 million. A 10% lower average realized price, to USD 85 per metric ton, and 20% higher all-in costs, to USD 60, driven by foreign exchange, higher diesel, and freight costs saw iron ore EBITDA fall 34% on a year ago, to USD 2.6 billion.

Fair value

Our fair value estimate for no-moat Vale is USD 15 per share.

We assume iron ore averages about USD 100 per metric ton from 2026 to 2029 based on the futures curve. Our assumed midcycle price is around USD 75 per metric ton from 2030 based on our estimate of the long run marginal cost of production. Solid demand from China, which accounts for around 75% of the seaborne iron ore trade, is supportive of near-term prices. However, longer-term we expect demand from China to moderate on declining steel production as its economy moves away from one reliant on fixed-asset investment to a more consumption-based economy. China’s falling population along with rising scrap-based production also contribute to reduced demand for iron ore in our view. We also think additional supply is likely, led by Simandou and Vale. Hence we expect a long-term price substantially below current spot of around USD 90 per metric ton.

Cuing off the futures curve, our assumed average copper price from 2026 to 2029 is about USD 6.50 per pound. Based on our estimate of the long run marginal cost of production, we assume a midcycle price of about USD 3.80 per pound from 2030.

In addition, we assume nickel prices of about USD 7.40 per pound from 2027, based on spot.

We assume a 9.2% cost of capital in our five-year explicit forecast and use an enterprise value/EBITDA multiple of 6 to value cash flows generated beyond year five.

Economic moat

As a commodity producer, Vale is a price taker and needs low-cost mines with long lives and a low installed capital base to support the longer-term excess returns needed to justify an economic moat. We forecast midcycle returns on invested capital similar to its weighted average cost of capital of about 9%. Its iron ore solutions segment accounts for about 80% of midcycle EBITDA, but ROIC is weighed down by its base metals business, which generates low returns on its invested capital base.

Our forecast is based on assumed midcycle prices from 2030 of roughly USD 75 per metric ton for iron ore (which we note is materially less than the average price of around USD 100 per metric ton over the past decade) and USD 3.80 per pound for copper, based on our estimates of the marginal costs of production. We also assume nickel prices of about USD 7.40 per pound from 2027 based on spot prices. As its midcycle ROIC is similar to its WACC, we don’t assign a moat to Vale.

In calculating ROIC, we have added back to invested capital about USD 39 billion in asset and intangible write-downs taken over the past decade on the basis that these amounts relate to assets developed or acquired in the ordinary course of business and so should be included when calculating ROIC. Some of the more material amounts include USD 17 billion in relation to nickel, USD 11 billion in relation to coal, and USD 6 billion in relation to fertilizers.

Looking at each of Vale’s segments in turn:

Iron ore solutions (no moat): Vale’s ore has an average iron content of around 63%-64%, higher than the 61%-62% produced by BHP and Rio Tinto and the 57%-58% produced by Fortescue. As such, it generates a premium compared with the 61% benchmark price. However, Vale’s iron ore assets have cash costs that place it around the middle of the seaborne iron ore cost curve, above its lower-cost competitors, including BHP and Rio, but better than Fortescue once the latter’s lower-quality ore (lower iron content) is taken into account. Anglo American and other smaller competitors also sit to the right of Vale on the industry cost curve. Vale’s competitive disadvantage versus its lower-cost Australian competitors is due to higher freight costs incurred to ship its ore to China, which accounts for around 75% of annual seaborne iron ore demand. With substantial resources, we think new mines will be periodically developed to continue to feed and utilize the installed infrastructure base of Vale’s three iron ore systems. The remainder of this segment is relatively immaterial. We estimate that the iron ore solutions segment will produce around 80% of midcycle EBITDA. However, the iron ore operations’ middling position on the industry cost curve means we think it is unlikely to generate returns above Vale’s cost of capital.

Base metals (no moat): The segment has an inflated capital base due to the purchase of Canada’s Inco in 2006 and the subsequent development of high-cost mines in Brazil and New Caledonia. Both the nickel and copper operations lack a cost advantage, with both located in the upper half of the relevant industry cost curves. We forecast nickel sales to rise to around 220,000 metric tons in 2030, up from about 170,000 metric tons in 2025, driven by increased production at its Canadian mines, led by Sudbury. We forecast copper sales to increase to about 420,000 metric tons in 2030, up from around 370,000 metric tons in 2025, driven by increased production at Salobo in Brazil and at its Canadian nickel mines, which also produce copper. This will likely lead to cash operating costs for both nickel and copper falling, but the company’s operations are likely to remain middling at best on the respective industry cost curves. We forecast this segment will produce around 20% of midcycle EBITDA. However, as we forecast low-single-digit returns on invested capital from midcycle, we don’t deem the base metals segment as moatworthy either.

Exploration projects (no moat): These are an immaterial part of Vale and way too early in their potential development to assign any of them a moat.

Bull case

Vale's lower unit costs relative to producers in India and China, as well as high-cost producers such as Anglo American, allow it to remain profitable even in depressed price environments.

Vale's high-quality ore with an iron content of around 63%-64% could attract significant premiums relative to the 61% benchmark.

Vale could benefit from efforts to decarbonize steelmaking. Steelmakers prefer higher-grade inputs, such as Vale’s iron ore, as they require less metallurgical coal and result in lower carbon emissions per metric ton of steel produced.

Bear case

We believe China's real estate- and infrastructure-driven economic growth has likely peaked, and prices for materials such as iron ore will decline.

The Brazilian government occasionally reviews mining royalties, which could allow it to extract further value from Vale's iron ore assets.

Vale's investments in nonferrous business lines, such as coal, nickel, and copper, have been procyclical and expensive, destroying value. Returns have been poor and have weighed down overall group returns.

By Jon Mills, CFA

Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:26 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.

Vale SA discussion 0 comments

Add a comment