Ferrovial SE
✦ Quant Fair Value how this is computed
- Implied fair-value range of 19.69-73.56, from this stock's own trailing 5-year average P/E applied to trailing EPS.
- Current price is +23.0% above the average-multiple fair value of 46.63.
Valuation each multiple against its own 5-year range
Vs. peers Engineering & Construction
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM)i | P/Bi | Div yieldi |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ferrovial SE (FER) | 41.18B | 61.52 | 6.56 | 2.20% |
| Quanta Services (PWR) | 84.23B | 50.59 | 8.00 | 0.08% |
| Comfort Systems USA (FIX) | 36.47B | 22.52 | 10.94 | 0.29% |
| EMCOR Group (EME) | 26.41B | 17.44 | 6.18 | 0.24% |
| APi Group (APG) | 17.89B | -75.13 | 5.13 | 0.00% |
| Jacobs Engineering (J) | 17.63B | 52.66 | 5.40 | 0.90% |
Other StockVane-tracked companies in the same industry.
Morningstar
Trading 55.2% below Morningstar's fair value estimate.
Analyst note
Ferrovial reported mixed third-quarter results, as strength in construction offset some traffic weakness in the concession portfolio. The group provided additional disclosures on the I-24 and I-285E awards, which was important, given that the uncertainty has been an overhang on the shares.
The bottom line: We have updated our estimates and maintain our EUR 80 fair value estimate. Our valuation of the Nasdaq-listed shares falls to $89 from $91 due to currency movements. We believe the shares are currently very undervalued and concerns about the I-24 and I-285E awards are misplaced. We lowered our 2026 traffic estimates across the managed lane concessions but expect a return to trend over 2027 and 2028 as fuel prices normalize and construction disruptions ease. This doesn’t have a large impact on asset values, given their long duration and formidable pricing power. We have yet to include the I-24 and I-285E assets in our sum of the parts, but our initial estimates (based on limited information) indicate they are both value-accretive. Following the Oct. 27 release, we are confident that the I-24 concession can achieve an equity internal rate of return in excess of 20% (versus the low-teens narrative).
Between the lines: The target for John F. Kennedy International Airport's New Terminal One phase A design-build-operate remains March 2027. Phases B1 and B2 have been deferred to no later than August 2033 and December 2035, respectively, which is later than we had assumed. We are still confident the asset will generate significant economic profits, since JFK is a slot-constrained, demand-rich hub and the new terminal will house one-third of JFK’s wide-body gates once complete. We expect the commencement of operations to act as a catalyst for the shares. Most investors value Ferrovial’s stake at a 1 times multiple of equity injected (EUR 1,042 million), while our discounted cash flow model implies an equity value to Ferrovial of over EUR 3.2 billion.
Following Oct. 27's additional disclosures on the I-24 concession, we wrote a note detailing our belief that Ferrovial could achieve an equity IRR in excess of 20% on the project. Before that, we believe the market unjustly had taken a "guilty until proved innocent" stance on the concessions, given the limited disclosures and exemplary track record of capital allocation. Investors were concerned that Ferrovial had accepted an equity IRR in the high single digits to low teens, which is incommensurate for a project of this complexity.
Even after Oct. 28's additional disclosures, our equity IRR estimate for the I-285E concession is no better than it was for I-24 before the Oct. 27 disclosure. On the call, management twice declined to rule out reprofiling the concession payments before financial close (the key positive surprise in the I-24 disclosure Oct. 27), and management was more limited in its characterization of the corridor traffic than it was for I-24. Without these key unknowns, we think it is unwise to assume Ferrovial has accepted an incommensurate equity IRR for the I-285E.
Fair value
Our fair value estimate is $89 per share. We triangulate our model-driven estimate with our sum-of-the-parts calculation, which better captures the long-duration—though finite—cash flows associated with build-operate-transfer infrastructure concessions.
Ferrovial’s 48.29% stake in 407 ETR contributes just under half of our fair value estimate. We expect revenue growth to moderate from 2027, after strong double-digit revenue per trip growth in 2024-26, partly a catch-up from a four-year pandemic-era rate freeze. Over its 25-year history, the asset has shown it can implement above-inflation average tariff increases without hurting traffic. We forecast average revenue per trip to grow 1.5% above our 2.3% Canada CPI forecast for the remainder of the concession. Toll increases drive most of our growth, but traffic should also rise with population growth and return-to-office trends. Our 4.9% revenue CAGR to 2098 reflects these traffic and toll forecasts, ahead of Ferrovial’s own 2018 estimates, due to higher inflation expectations and toll hikes we think achievable. EBITDA margin should expand beyond 84% given mostly fixed operating costs. We forecast maintenance capital expenditures averaging 2.1% of sales, in line with 2018 disclosures. We use a 5.1% asset-level WACC (50/50 debt/equity, 7% cost of equity, 4.37% cost of debt).
US managed lanes contribute 37% to our fair value estimate. We view the location of Ferrovial’s toll roads very favorably: Dallas-Fort Worth, Charlotte, and Northern Virginia all boast affluent and growing catchment areas that support long-term pricing power. We forecast revenue per transaction to at least double in real terms over the remaining life, implying toll growth 2.0%-2.5% above our 2.3% US CPI assumption, with 5%-6% revenue CAGR and margin benefits from operating leverage. Our base case excludes new concession awards. We use the 6.5% group WACC to value these assets and do not include recent awards for I-24 and I-285E.
Ferrovial’s 49% stake in JFK's New Terminal One contributes 5.3% of our fair value estimate. The terminal is set to open in March 2027. Ferrovial has disclosed limited operating economics, so our estimates rely on peer comparisons and bond disclosures. We’re constructive on a quick ramp, given the shortage of wide-body aircraft gates at JFK and the agreements already secured with around 32 carriers, including CPI plus 1% annual escalators on cost per enplanement, with further repricing scope after contracts expire. We estimate an initial CPE of $85 (raising this to $100 increases our group fair value estimate by 2%), with CPE contributing 75% of New Terminal One revenue and the balance from other aeronautical/nonaeronautical sources. We estimate an 80% midcycle EBITDA margin, with Port Authority of New York and New Jersey fees below this line. We use a 5.3% asset-level WACC, with higher debt weighting offsetting a 9% COE estimate reflecting the project's nascency.
The balance of our fair value estimate comprises Ferrovial’s construction businesses (Ferrovial Construction, Budimex, and Webber), energy segment, Spanish and Portuguese toll roads, and Dalaman Airport stake. We use a 4 times enterprise value/EBITDA multiple for Ferrovial Construction and Webber, and we mark to market Ferrovial’s 51% stake in listed Budimex. We also mark to market Ferrovial’s 20% direct stake in IRB Infrastructure Developers and add the book value of Ferrovial’s stake in IRB Infrastructure Trust, which owns a portfolio of 14 toll road concessions in India. We value Ferrovial’s legacy Spanish and Portuguese toll roads using a 4 times EV/EBITDA multiple and add its 60% stake in Dalaman Airport at book value. We then add the holding company’s net cash balance—after stripping out Budimex’s share—to the equity value.
Economic moat
We assign a Wide Morningstar Economic Moat Rating to Ferrovial. We believe its unique portfolio and pipeline of predominantly lightly regulated infrastructure concessions benefit from efficient scale and intangible asset moat sources.
We believe transport infrastructure concessions have the potential to benefit from efficient scale and intangible moat sources. When a catchment area's demand is being adequately serviced by an incumbent, it becomes economically irrational and often physically impossible to duplicate the piece of infrastructure, which characterizes an efficient scale moat. The exclusive right to charge for use (the concession) is an exemplar of a regulatory intangible asset.
Project internal rates of return, not returns on invested capital, better capture lifetime economic profit for concessions, since they carry a large amortizing intangible asset that depresses early ROIC and inflates it later. Accordingly, we look for positive net present values and IRRs above the weighted average cost of capital when investments are made. Ferrovial aims to underwrite infrastructure investments with a post-tax equity IRR in the double digits, with the exact level contingent on the project's complexity. Ferrovial no longer discloses its asset-level IRR estimates, but since it last did in 2018, its key assets—407 ETR, North Tarrant Express 35W, and LBJ Express lanes—have all progressed ahead of those forecasts.
Ferrovial’s stake in 407 ETR earns a wide moat. The 99-year concession, awarded in 1999, grants the exclusive right to toll, collect on, and enforce use of the highway—a right that cannot be replicated, since no competing route can be built through the same corridor. This exclusivity is compounded by a toll formula that lets pricing power outrun inflation: minimum increases tracked CPI plus 2% until 2014 and 100% of CPI since, with full discretion to raise tolls further, provided that traffic exceeds set thresholds. Below-threshold traffic instead triggers a Schedule 22 payment to the government equal to 2 times the annual segment tariff revenue times the percentage of traffic under the threshold. Inelastic demand has worked in the concessionaire’s favor, allowing peak toll rates to rise 8.5 times since 1999 (8.6% compound annual growth rate) even after a toll freeze during 2020-24.
The efficient scale moat rests on 407 ETR’s position traversing the congested and growing Greater Toronto area. The affluent population is set to grow 22% by 2051, while the main free alternatives (Highways 401 and 403 and the Queen Elizabeth Way) are already severely congested at peak times; a Steer study estimates commuters can save up to two hours a day by using 407 ETR. Planned expansions to alternative routes are unlikely to close this gap, since population growth should absorb the added capacity. Vehicle kilometers traveled grew at a 1.9% CAGR over 2010-20, just behind our GDP per capita growth estimate for the area but far steadier, reflecting toll roads’ resilience through downturns.
Ferrovial’s US managed lanes earn the same wide moat and for the same reasons as 407 ETR: an exclusive, unreplicable right to toll, paired with inelastic demand from commuters facing congested free alternatives. The TEXpress network (LBJ Express, NTE, NTE 35W) in Dallas-Fort Worth, I-77 in Charlotte, and I-66 in Northern Virginia all serve growing affluent populations ahead of the national average, reinforcing demand as concessions run to at least 2061. We expect all routes to raise real toll rates at least twofold over the remainder of the concession and estimate all have a positive net present value, using our group 6.5% WACC estimate.
New Terminal One will earn a wide moat once it opens in early 2027. Ferrovial owns 49% of the 35-year concession to build, operate, and maintain what aims to be the highest-quality terminal serving the New York City metro area. JFK is slot-constrained and demand-rich, and a greenfield competitor is effectively impossible given airspace, land, and regulatory limits. Once complete, the terminal will house one-third of JFK’s wide-body gates; with 32 carrier agreements already signed, including anchors Etihad, Air France, and Qatar Airways, we expect it to reach capacity quickly. The terminal will charge an entirely unregulated cost-per-enplanement fee, which is expected to generate around three-fourths of the concessions revenue. We understand contracts with carriers are 5-15 years in duration, including a CPI plus 1% annual adjustment, and each renewal is an opportunity to set them higher. Switching costs reinforce this, since once a carrier has built out lounges, ground handling, and connectivity at the terminal, relocating means rebuilding all of it elsewhere.
We award no moat to Ferrovial’s construction businesses, which compete with EPC firms like Vinci, Bouygues, ACS Group/Hochtief, Kiewit, and Skanska on tendered contracts. Generally, we do not award EPC firms economic moats due to intense competition, significant customer power, and the commoditized nature of many projects, even the most critical and complex. The result is thin margins with no buffer against continuous execution risk—cost overruns from exogenous shocks such as bad weather or volatile raw material prices routinely eat what little margin exists. Therefore, firms struggle to generate durable excess returns on capital over the cycle.
This doesn’t affect our overall rating for the group, however, since the construction businesses give Ferrovial a platform that can improve bid competitiveness, delivery control, and risk management on infrastructure developments.
Bull case
407 ETR has proved it can increase earnings well ahead of inflation, and the concession still has 72 years remaining.
New Terminal One at JFK should ramp quickly once it opens, given its focus on international wide-body aircraft gates, which are in high demand.
There’s still ample runway for capital redeployment in North American public/private toll roads, as evidenced by Ferrovial's recent awards for I-24 and I-285E.
Bear case
Construction businesses can face cost overruns resulting from factors beyond their control, such as weather.
If investments are underwritten with overly optimistic estimates, projects can become insolvent due to the high levels of debt carried in the SPVs, as was the case with the Indiana Toll Road and State Highway 130.
Competition for infrastructure assets could rise in the coming years as private capital allocations increase.
By Jack Fletcher-Price
Quote time 2026-11-20 20:02:16 · For reference only, not investment advice and not tailored to your situation.
Ferrovial SE discussion 0 comments